Simple and Non-Simple Rotations at $n=4$: the Two Angles and the Isoclinic Families
Introduction
At order four a rotation has two invariant planes and two angles, the normal form $\operatorname{diag}(R_{\theta_1},R_{\theta_2})$, and the generic rotation is not simple; the isoclinic cases $\theta_1=\pm\theta_2$ are the two families, each a three-sphere of rotations, and the circle of one family is the Hopf action of $S^{1}$ on $S^{3}$.
The article defines simplicity, proves that a simple rotation of four-space fixes a plane and has one angle, classifies the rotations into the three cases of distinct angles, equal angles and opposite angles, gives the count $\lfloor n/2\rfloor$, identifies the two angles with the two summands of $\mathfrak{so}(4)$, and relates the isoclinic families to the Hopf fibration.
It assumes The Spectral Theorem: the Anti-Hermitian Case and the Reality of the Spectrum at $n=4$, The Lie Algebra $\operatorname{Skew}_4\cong\mathfrak{so}(4)$ and The Rotor as a Square Root of a Rotation: the Two Signs and the Double Cover at $n=4$. The general order is Simple and Non-Simple Rotations: One Angle at $n\le3$, Two Angles at $n\ge4$.
Simple Rotations and the Fixed Subspace
Definition. A rotation is simple when it turns a single plane and fixes its orthogonal complement pointwise.
Proposition. A simple rotation of four-space has the eigenvalue $1$ with multiplicity at least two, and its fixed subspace is a plane.
Proof. The fixed complement of the rotating plane is two-dimensional and consists of eigenvectors with eigenvalue one; the rotating plane contributes the eigenvalues $e^{\pm i\theta}$.
Corollary. A simple rotation is $\operatorname{diag}(R_\theta,\mathrm I_2)$ in a suitable orthonormal frame, and the rank of $Q-\mathrm I_4$ is two.
Proof. The normal form of the two blocks, and the kernel of $Q-\mathrm I_4$ is the fixed plane.
Proposition. A rotation of four-space is simple exactly when the eigenvalue one has multiplicity at least two, that is when the geometric multiplicity of one exceeds one.
Proof. The multiplicity of the eigenvalue one is the dimension of the fixed space, which for a simple rotation is two; conversely two independent fixed vectors span a fixed plane whose complement is turned by a single angle.
Corollary. The simple rotations form a family of dimension five, of codimension one in the six-dimensional group: the choice of the plane costs four parameters and the angle one.
Proof. The normal form and the dimension count: a plane in four-space is a point of the Grassmannian of dimension four, and the angle adds one.
The axis at order three. At order three a rotation always has a fixed line, so every rotation is simple; at order four the fixed space can be a line or a point, and the generic rotation fixes only the origin.
Proof. An odd-dimensional real operator has a real eigenvalue, which for an orthogonal one is $\pm1$ and hence a fixed line after possibly reversing the sign.
The Two Angles at Order Four
Theorem. Every rotation of four-space is orthogonally conjugate to $\operatorname{diag}(R_{\theta_1},R_{\theta_2})$ with $\theta_1\ge\theta_2\ge0$, up to signs and ordering.
Proof. The real normal form of the anti-Hermitian generator, exponentiated: the pair of invariant planes of the anti-Hermitian part is invariant under the rotation it generates.
Corollary. The spectrum is $\{e^{i\theta_1},e^{-i\theta_1},e^{i\theta_2},e^{-i\theta_2}\}$, and the two angles are read from it up to sign.
Proof. The eigenvalues of the two blocks.
Corollary. $\operatorname{tr}Q=2\cos\theta_1+2\cos\theta_2$ and $\det Q=1$, so the trace is the sum of the two cosines and the determinant carries no information.
Proof. Sum and product of the eigenvalues.
The angle formula. For a simple rotation $\operatorname{tr}Q=2+2\cos\theta$, which recovers the angle from the trace; at order four the single trace determines the sum of the two cosines and not the two angles separately.
Proof. The two formulas.
Corollary. The map from the rotation to its trace is not injective at order four, and it cannot be, since the group has dimension six and the trace takes values in a two-dimensional real set.
Proof. The trace is a continuous function of two parameters into a bounded interval on a six-dimensional group.
The Three Cases
Theorem. A rotation of four-space falls in exactly one of four cases:
| case | condition | fixed space | simple |
|---|---|---|---|
| simple | $\theta_1\neq0$, $\theta_2=0$ | a plane | yes |
| isoclinic, left | $\theta_1=\theta_2\neq0$ | a point | no |
| isoclinic, right | $\theta_1=-\theta_2\neq0$ | a point | no |
| general | $|\theta_1|\neq|\theta_2|$, both nonzero | a point | no |
Proof. A block $R_\theta$ of a nonzero angle contributes no fixed vector, so the fixed space is spanned by the blocks with $\theta=0$: it is a plane when exactly one angle vanishes and the origin otherwise. A rotation is simple exactly when it is a single block together with an untouched plane.
Corollary. The isoclinic rotations split into two families, $\theta_1=\theta_2$ and $\theta_1=-\theta_2$, and the two families are the left and the right one-sided quaternion actions; both families fix only the origin.
Proof. The left action turns both planes in the same sense and the right action in opposite senses; in either case both planes move.
Corollary. A non-isoclinic rotation has no fixed vector and no invariant vector at all, since an invariant vector would be an eigenvector with a real eigenvalue.
Proof. The eigenvalues are not real for a nonzero angle.
The generic case. The generic rotation is non-isoclinic with two distinct nonzero angles, so the generic rotation is not simple.
Proof. The conditions $\theta_1=\pm\theta_2$ and $\theta_k=0$ are of codimension one or more in the two parameters.
The Count and the Normal Form
Proposition. The number of independent angles is $\lfloor n/2\rfloor$, which is $1$ at $n=2,3$ and $2$ at $n=4,5$.
Proof. The maximal torus of $SO(n)$ has dimension $\lfloor n/2\rfloor$, one circle per invariant plane.
Corollary. At order four the rotation group has dimension six and rank two, and the two angles are the coordinates on a maximal torus.
Proof. $\dim SO(4)=6$, the rank is two, and the remaining four dimensions are the choice of the two planes.
Corollary. The normal form is $\operatorname{diag}(R_{\theta_1},R_{\theta_2})$, and the two planes of the normal form are the eigenplanes of the anti-Hermitian generator.
Proof. The normal form of the antisymmetric matrix, exponentiated.
The order five. At order five a third angle exists but the extra dimension is a fixed line, so the count is still two; the first order with three angles is six.
Proof. $\lfloor5/2\rfloor=2$ and $\lfloor6/2\rfloor=3$.
The Two Angles as the Two Parameters
Proposition. The two angles are the parameters of the two summands of $\mathfrak{so}(4)=\mathfrak{sl}_2\oplus\mathfrak{sl}_2$: the self-dual part has size $\theta_1$ and the anti-self-dual part size $\theta_2$.
Proof. $\tfrac12(A+\ast A)=\theta_1J_1$ and $\tfrac12(A-\ast A)=\theta_2J_2$ in the normal form, and the two summands are the two eigenspaces of the star.
Corollary. The simple rotations are those with one summand vanishing, and the isoclinic rotations are those whose two summands have equal size.
Proof. A vanishing self-dual part means $\theta_1=0$, which is a rotation in one plane only, and equal sizes means $|\theta_1|=|\theta_2|$.
Corollary. The two angles are independent coordinates, and the rotation group is the product of the two circle groups of the summands modulo the diagonal sign.
Proof. Each summand contributes one circle, and the pair of signs $(-1,-1)$ acts trivially.
The biquaternion form. A rotation is $L_pR_q$ with $p,q$ unit quaternions, and the two angles are the arguments of $p$ and of $q$.
Proof. $p=e^{\theta_1 i}$ turns both planes by $\theta_1$ and $q=e^{\theta_2 i}$ turns them by $\theta_2$ with opposite senses, so the product has the two angles.
The Isoclinic Rotations and the Hopf Fibrations
Theorem. The left-isoclinic rotations form a copy of $S^{3}$ inside $SO(4)$, and so do the right-isoclinic ones; their intersection is $\pm\mathrm I_4$.
Proof. The left unit quaternions form a three-sphere of rotations, the right ones another, and a rotation that is both is $\pm\mathrm I_4$ because its two angles satisfy $\theta_1=\theta_2$ and $\theta_1=-\theta_2$.
Corollary. The two three-spheres generate $SO(4)$ and intersect in two points, which is the double cover $\mathrm{Spin}(4)\to SO(4)$ read on the two factors.
Proof. Every rotation is a product of one from each, and the intersection is the kernel.
The Hopf reading. The circle $\{e^{i\theta}\}\subset S^{3}$ of left-isoclinic rotations through a plane acts on the unit sphere $S^{3}\subset\mathbb{C}^{2}$ as the Hopf action, whose orbits are the fibres of $S^{3}\to S^{2}$.
Proof. Writing $\mathbb{R}^{4}=\mathbb{C}^{2}$, the left multiplication by $e^{i\theta}$ is the scalar multiplication by the phase, and the orbit map of the unit sphere is the Hopf fibration.
Corollary. The isoclinic circle is the structure group of the Hopf bundle at order four, and the full three-sphere of left-isoclinic rotations is the total space of the same fibration.
Proof. The action of $S^{3}$ on its own unit sphere by left multiplication is free and transitive, and the circle inside it gives the fibres.
The next level. The same construction with $\mathbb{H}^{2}$ in place of $\mathbb{C}^{2}$, that is at order eight, gives the quaternionic Hopf fibration $S^{7}\to S^{4}$, whose structure group is the three-sphere of unit quaternions.
Proof. Left multiplication by unit quaternions on $\mathbb{H}^{2}=\mathbb{R}^{8}$ preserves the norm and acts freely on the unit sphere, with quotient the quaternionic projective line $S^{4}$.
Corollary. The isoclinic phenomenon is the geometric content of the Hopf fibrations, and at order four it is the complex one.
Proof. The two statements above.
Summary
A rotation of four-space has two invariant planes and two angles, with the normal form $\operatorname{diag}(R_{\theta_1},R_{\theta_2})$; it is simple exactly when one angle is zero or the two are opposite, so the fixed space is a plane in those cases and a point otherwise. The generic rotation is non-isoclinic and not simple.
The number of angles is $\lfloor n/2\rfloor$, one at orders two and three and two from order four on. The two angles are the parameters of the two summands of $\mathfrak{so}(4)$, and the isoclinic families are the rotations with one summand vanishing.
The left-isoclinic and right-isoclinic rotations are two three-spheres meeting in two points, and their product is the whole group; the circle inside one of them is the Hopf action of $S^{1}$ on $S^{3}$, and the same construction at order eight gives the quaternionic Hopf fibration.
Summary of Notation
| Symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
| $R_\theta$ | the rotation block of angle $\theta$ |
| $\theta_1,\theta_2$ | the two angles |
| $\lfloor n/2\rfloor$ | the number of angles |
| isoclinic | $\theta_1=\pm\theta_2$ |
| $S^{3}\to S^{2}$ | the Hopf fibration of the isoclinic circle |
Further Reading
- Morton L. Curtis, Matrix Groups (Springer, 1984), for the normal form of a rotation and the two angles.
- Simple and Non-Simple Rotations: One Angle at $n\le3$, Two Angles at $n\ge4$, for the statement at general order.
- The Spectral Theorem: the Anti-Hermitian Case and the Reality of the Spectrum at $n=4$, for the eigenvalues and the Pfaffian.
- The Lie Algebra $\operatorname{Skew}_4\cong\mathfrak{so}(4)$, for the two summands.
- Simple Rotations at $n=2$: Why There Is Only One Angle, for the case at order two.