The Cubic, the Discriminant and the Spectral Strata of $M_3(\mathbb{C})$

Introduction

Every element $A\in M_{3}(\mathbb{C})$ has a characteristic polynomial of degree three, $$ \chi_{A}(\lambda)=\det(\lambda I-A)=\lambda^{3}-t\lambda^{2}+s\lambda-d, $$ with $$ t=\operatorname{tr}A,\qquad s=\tfrac12\bigl(t^{2}-\operatorname{tr}A^{2}\bigr),\qquad d=\det A. $$ The three roots, counted with multiplicity, are the eigenvalues. The discriminant $\Delta$ is the product of the squared differences of the roots: $$ \Delta=\prod_{i

The construction is root-first. For a root $H$ with $H^{3}=I$ and simple spectrum the three eigenvalues are the cube roots of unity, and the Lagrange projectors $P_{1},P_{2},P_{3}$ are the idempotents of Roots of Unity and the Lagrange Idempotents of $M_3(\mathbb{C})$. The general element of this article need not be a root: its eigenvalues are arbitrary complex numbers, and the cubic is the general cubic. The root case is the special case $t=0$, $s=0$, $d=1$ up to the ordering of the roots, since $\lambda^{3}-1=0$.

The article uses the trace and the determinant of The Matrix Algebra $M_{3}(\mathbb{C})$, the Peirce coordinates of The Peirce Decomposition of $M_{3}(\mathbb{C})$, and the Jordan decomposition of The Element, the Coordinates and the Trace of $M_3(\mathbb{C})$. The spectral theorem for a single matrix is the content here; the Hermitian spectral theorem is The Involution and the Hermitian Structure of $M_3(\mathbb{C})$.

The Characteristic Cubic

Definition. For $A\in M_{3}(\mathbb{C})$ the characteristic polynomial is $\chi_{A}(\lambda)=\det(\lambda I-A)$, and the three coefficients are $$ t=\operatorname{tr}A,\qquad s=\tfrac12\bigl((\operatorname{tr}A)^{2}-\operatorname{tr}A^{2}\bigr),\qquad d=\det A. $$

Proposition. The polynomial is $$ \chi_{A}(\lambda)=\lambda^{3}-t\lambda^{2}+s\lambda-d, $$ and its roots are the eigenvalues of $A$, counted with algebraic multiplicity.

Proof. Expand the determinant of $\lambda I-A$ by the Leibniz formula. The constant term is $\det(-A)=-\det A$; the coefficient of $\lambda^{3}$ is $1$; the coefficient of $\lambda^{2}$ is $-\operatorname{tr}A$; the coefficient of $\lambda$ is the sum of the principal $2\times2$ minors: $$ s=(a_{11}a_{22}-a_{12}a_{21})+(a_{11}a_{33}-a_{13}a_{31})+(a_{22}a_{33}-a_{23}a_{32}). $$ The trace identity $s=\tfrac12(t^{2}-\operatorname{tr}A^{2})$ follows by expanding $t^{2}=\sum_{i,j}a_{ii}a_{jj}$ and $\operatorname{tr}A^{2}=\sum_{i,j}a_{ij}a_{ji}$ and subtracting. The roots are the eigenvalues by the fundamental theorem of algebra, and the algebraic multiplicities are the multiplicities of the roots.

Cayley–Hamilton. $\chi_{A}(A)=0$. This is the Cayley–Hamilton theorem of The Matrix Algebra $M_{3}(\mathbb{C})$; it implies that every power $A^{n}$ with $n\geq3$ is a linear combination of $I,A,A^{2}$, and that the algebra $\mathbb{C}[A]$ has dimension at most three.

The root case. For $H$ with $H^{3}=I$ and simple spectrum, the eigenvalues are $1,\omega,\omega^{2}$, so $$ \chi_{H}(\lambda)=\lambda^{3}-1, $$ with $t=0$, $s=0$, $d=1$. The three Lagrange projectors of Roots of Unity and the Lagrange Idempotents of $M_3(\mathbb{C})$ are the spectral projectors of this cubic. The general cubic of this article is the deformation of $\lambda^{3}-1$ in which the three roots move independently.

The trace and the determinant of the roots. By Vieta, $$ \lambda_{1}+\lambda_{2}+\lambda_{3}=t,\qquad \lambda_{1}\lambda_{2}+\lambda_{2}\lambda_{3}+\lambda_{3}\lambda_{1}=s,\qquad \lambda_{1}\lambda_{2}\lambda_{3}=d. $$ These are the elementary symmetric functions of the spectrum. The coefficients $t,s,d$ are polynomial in the nine entries, of degrees $1,2,3$ respectively, and they are invariant under conjugation.

The Discriminant

Definition. For a monic cubic $\lambda^{3}-t\lambda^{2}+s\lambda-d$ with roots $\lambda_{1},\lambda_{2},\lambda_{3}$, the discriminant is $$ \Delta=\prod_{i

Theorem (the discriminant in the coefficients). $$ \boxed{\;\Delta=t^{2}s^{2}-4s^{3}-4t^{3}d+18tsd-27d^{2}.\;} $$

Proof. The discriminant of a cubic $x^{3}+ax^{2}+bx+c$ is $$ a^{2}b^{2}-4b^{3}-4a^{3}c+18abc-27c^{2}. $$ Substituting $a=-t$, $b=s$, $c=-d$ gives $$ t^{2}s^{2}-4s^{3}-4t^{3}d+18tsd-27d^{2}. $$ The formula is the standard discriminant of the cubic; it is also obtained by eliminating $\lambda$ from $\chi$ and $\chi'$, or by expanding the Vandermonde product.

The discriminant detects a repeated root. Over $\mathbb{C}$, the cubic has a repeated root if and only if $\Delta=0$.

Proof. If $\lambda_{i}=\lambda_{j}$ for $i\neq j$, the product has a zero factor. Conversely, if $\Delta=0$, some difference $\lambda_{i}-\lambda_{j}$ is zero, because $\mathbb{C}$ is a field and a product is zero only when a factor is zero.

The resultant form. For a monic cubic, $$ \operatorname{Res}(\chi,\chi')=\prod_{i}\chi'(\lambda_{i})=\prod_{i\neq j}(\lambda_{i}-\lambda_{j})=(-1)^{3}\prod_{i

Homogeneity. The coefficients $t,s,d$ have degrees $1,2,3$ in the entries, and every term of $\Delta$ has degree $6$: $t^{2}s^{2}$ has $2+4=6$, $s^{3}$ has $6$, $t^{3}d$ has $3+3=6$, $tsd$ has $1+2+3=6$, $d^{2}$ has $6$. So $\Delta$ is a homogeneous polynomial of degree $6$ in the nine entries. It is invariant under conjugation, because $t,s,d$ are.

Worked example. For $$ A=\begin{pmatrix}1&2&3\\4&5&6\\7&8&9\end{pmatrix}, $$ the trace is $15$, and $$ \operatorname{tr}A^{2}=30+81+150=261, $$ because the diagonal of $A^{2}$ is $(30,81,150)$. Hence $$ s=\tfrac12(15^{2}-261)=\tfrac12(225-261)=-18,\qquad d=0, $$ and $$ \chi_{A}(\lambda)=\lambda^{3}-15\lambda^{2}-18\lambda=\lambda(\lambda^{2}-15\lambda-18). $$ The roots are $$ 0,\qquad \frac{15+\sqrt{297}}{2},\qquad \frac{15-\sqrt{297}}{2}, $$ because $15^{2}+4\cdot18=225+72=297$. The discriminant is $$ \Delta=15^{2}(-18)^{2}-4(-18)^{3}=225\cdot324+4\cdot5832=72900+23328=96228. $$ The Vandermonde check gives $$ \left(\frac{15+\sqrt{297}}{2}\right)\left(\frac{15-\sqrt{297}}{2}\right)\sqrt{297} =\frac{225-297}{4}\sqrt{297} =-18\sqrt{297}, $$ whose square is $324\cdot297=96228$. The three principal $2\times2$ minors are $-3,-12,-3$, and their sum is $-18=s$, as it must be.

The root case in the formula. For $t=0$, $s=0$, $d=1$, the discriminant is $\Delta=-27(1)^{2}=-27$. The roots $1,\omega,\omega^{2}$ give $$ (1-\omega)^{2}(1-\omega^{2})^{2}(\omega-\omega^{2})^{2}=-27, $$ which is the product of the three squared differences; the negative sign is the sign of the Vandermonde product for three roots. The discriminant of $\lambda^{3}-1$ is $-27$, not $+27$; the ordering of the roots is part of the definition of the Vandermonde product.

The Spectral Strata

The three strata. The spectrum of $A$ falls into one of three multiplicity patterns:

  1. Simple spectrum: three distinct roots, $\Delta\neq0$.
  2. Double root: one root of multiplicity two and one simple root, $\Delta=0$ but $\chi\neq(\lambda-a)^{3}$.
  3. Triple root: one root of multiplicity three, $\chi=(\lambda-a)^{3}$.

Theorem (the dimensions). In $M_{3}(\mathbb{C})$, of complex dimension $9$ and real dimension $18$, the strata have dimensions

Stratum Condition Complex dimension Real dimension
simple spectrum $\Delta\neq0$ $9$ $18$
double root $\Delta=0$, not triple $8$ $16$
triple root $\chi=(\lambda-a)^{3}$ $7$ $14$

The simple stratum is open and dense; the double stratum is a hypersurface minus the triple stratum; the triple stratum is a codimension-two subvariety of the algebra, of codimension one in the discriminant hypersurface.

Proof. The simple stratum is the complement of the zero set of the polynomial $\Delta$, which is not identically zero; a nonzero polynomial vanishes on a hypersurface, so the complement is open and dense, of dimension $9$.

The discriminant $\Delta$ is one polynomial in the entries, not identically zero, so its zero set has dimension $8$; the double stratum is the part of this hypersurface where the cubic is not a cube, and it has dimension $8$ as well (removing a proper subvariety does not change the dimension).

The triple-root condition is $\chi=(\lambda-a)^{3}$ for some $a$, equivalently $$ t=3a,\qquad s=3a^{2},\qquad d=a^{3}. $$ Eliminating $a$ gives the two equations $$ s=\frac{t^{2}}{3},\qquad d=\frac{t^{3}}{27}, $$ which are independent, so the triple stratum has dimension $9-2=7$. Equivalently, every matrix with a triple root is $aI+N$ with $N$ nilpotent; the scalar $a$ contributes one dimension, and the nilpotent cone in $M_{3}$ is the set $\chi=x^{3}$, equivalently $t=s=d=0$, of dimension $9-3=6$, so the total is $1+6=7$. The scalar matrices $aI$ form the one-dimensional semisimple part of this stratum. The double stratum is the discriminant hypersurface minus the triple stratum, hence of dimension $8$.

The generic Jordan forms. The three strata have the following generic Jordan forms:

Stratum Generic Jordan form Centraliser dimension
simple $\operatorname{diag}(\lambda_{1},\lambda_{2},\lambda_{3})$, distinct $3$
double $\operatorname{diag}(J_{2}(a),b)$, $a\neq b$ $3$
triple $J_{3}(a)$ $3$

The centraliser of a generic element is three-dimensional in all three cases; the difference is the structure of the centraliser, not its dimension. For the simple spectrum it is the diagonal torus $\mathbb{C}^{\times}\times\mathbb{C}^{\times}\times\mathbb{C}^{\times}$, of dimension $3$; for the double root it is $\mathbb{C}[A]\cong\mathbb{C}[x]/((x-a)^{2}(x-b))$, of dimension $3$, with a nilpotent; for the triple root it is $\mathbb{C}[A]\cong\mathbb{C}[x]/((x-a)^{3})$, of dimension $3$, local.

The centraliser of a cyclic element. An element $A$ is cyclic when its minimal polynomial has degree $3$, equivalently when $\mathbb{C}[A]$ has dimension $3$, equivalently when there is a vector $v$ such that $v,Av,A^{2}v$ is a basis. For a cyclic element the centraliser is exactly $\mathbb{C}[A]$, of dimension $3$.

Proof. The centraliser of $A$ contains $\mathbb{C}[A]$. Conversely, if $B$ commutes with $A$, then $B$ is determined by $Bv$: the vectors $v,Av,A^{2}v$ are a basis, and $BA^{k}v=A^{k}Bv$ for every $k$, so the values of $B$ on the basis are determined by $Bv$, which is a vector of $\mathbb{C}^{3}$; hence the centraliser has dimension at most $3$. Since $\mathbb{C}[A]$ already has dimension $3$ for a cyclic element, the two are equal.

The torus case. For a cyclic element with simple spectrum, $\mathbb{C}[A]\cong\mathbb{C}[x]/(\chi)\cong\mathbb{C}\times\mathbb{C}\times\mathbb{C}$ by the Chinese remainder theorem, and the centraliser is the diagonal torus of dimension $3$. For a cyclic element with a repeated root, the algebra $\mathbb{C}[A]$ has nilpotents and is not a torus, but its dimension is still $3$. The menu phrase “the centraliser of a cyclic element is the torus of dimension three” refers to the simple-spectrum case; the repeated-root case has the same dimension and a different algebra.

The scalar element. The scalar $aI$ is not cyclic: its minimal polynomial is $x-a$, of degree one, and its centraliser is all of $M_{3}$, of dimension $9$. The scalars are exactly the elements whose centraliser has dimension $9$; the centraliser dimension is upper semicontinuous and jumps up on the smaller strata, with the scalar line at the top.

The Spectral Projectors at a Repeated Root

The simple case. If the spectrum is simple, the Lagrange projectors are $$ P_{k}=\prod_{l\neq k}\frac{A-\lambda_{l}I}{\lambda_{k}-\lambda_{l}},\qquad k=1,2,3, $$ with $P_{k}^{2}=P_{k}$, $P_{k}P_{l}=0$ for $k\neq l$, $\sum_{k}P_{k}=I$, and $AP_{k}=\lambda_{k}P_{k}$. They are the spectral projectors of Roots of Unity and the Lagrange Idempotents of $M_3(\mathbb{C})$, with the cube roots replaced by the three eigenvalues.

The double root. Suppose the spectrum is $\{a,a,b\}$ with $a\neq b$. The Lagrange formula on the distinct eigenvalues gives $$ P_{a}=\frac{A-bI}{a-b},\qquad P_{b}=\frac{A-aI}{b-a}, $$ and these are well defined because $a-b\neq0$. The projector $P_{a}$ has rank $2$: it is the spectral projector onto the generalised eigenspace of $a$, not onto a single line. The projector $P_{b}$ has rank $1$. They satisfy $P_{a}+P_{b}=I$, $P_{a}P_{b}=0$, and $AP_{a}=aP_{a}+N_{a}$ with $N_{a}=P_{a}N$ nilpotent; on the generalised eigenspace the matrix is $aI+N$, and $P_{a}$ is the projection onto that space, not a diagonalisation of $A$.

The degeneration. Split the double root into $a+\varepsilon$ and $a-\varepsilon$. For $\varepsilon\neq0$ the spectrum is simple, and there are two rank-one Lagrange projectors $P_{+}(\varepsilon)$ and $P_{-}(\varepsilon)$ with $$ P_{+}(\varepsilon)+P_{-}(\varepsilon)\longrightarrow P_{a}\qquad(\varepsilon\to0). $$ The individual limits depend on the splitting: in a basis where the generalised eigenspace of $a$ is spanned by $u,v$ and $A$ acts by $aI+N$, a perturbation that splits the eigenvalues chooses a direction in that plane, and the two rank-one projectors tend to the projections onto the two lines of that direction. Different perturbations give different pairs of lines; only the sum is canonical. This is the degeneration of the Lagrange projectors: the Lagrange interpolation is continuous in the eigenvalues as long as they are distinct, but at a collision the individual projectors have no canonical limit, while their sum over the colliding cluster is the Dunford projector.

The Dunford calculus. The canonical projector is the residue $$ P_{a}=\frac{1}{2\pi i}\oint_{\gamma}(\lambda I-A)^{-1}\,d\lambda, $$ where $\gamma$ is a small circle around $a$ enclosing no other eigenvalue. The contour integral is well defined at a repeated root and gives the spectral projector onto the generalised eigenspace. The Lagrange formula is the evaluation of the same contour integral when the roots are simple; at a collision the contour encloses both roots and the two Lagrange projectors are replaced by their sum.

The triple root. If $\chi=(\lambda-a)^{3}$, the only eigenvalue is $a$ and the spectral projector is $P_{a}=I$. The Jordan decomposition is $A=aI+N$ with $N$ nilpotent, and the "spectral" content is the single scalar $a$; the nilpotent $N$ is not detected by the spectrum. The Lagrange formula has all denominators zero and no limit that separates the three roots; the Dunford projector is $I$, and the finer decomposition is the Jordan decomposition of $N$, not a spectral decomposition.

Worked example of the double root. Let $$ A=\begin{pmatrix}a&1&0\\0&a&0\\0&0&b\end{pmatrix},\qquad a\neq b. $$ Then $\chi=(\lambda-a)^{2}(\lambda-b)$, and $$ P_{a}=\frac{A-bI}{a-b}=\begin{pmatrix}1&0&0\\0&1&0\\0&0&0\end{pmatrix},\qquad P_{b}=\frac{A-aI}{b-a}=\begin{pmatrix}0&0&0\\0&0&0\\0&0&1\end{pmatrix}. $$ The projector $P_{a}$ has rank $2$ and does not diagonalise the Jordan block: $AP_{a}=aP_{a}+E_{12}$, with $E_{12}$ nilpotent. The Lagrange projectors of a nearby matrix with eigenvalues $a\pm\varepsilon$ tend to two rank-one projectors whose sum is $P_{a}$; the individual limits depend on the perturbation.

Summary

The characteristic cubic of $A\in M_{3}(\mathbb{C})$ is $$ \boxed{\;\chi_{A}(\lambda)=\lambda^{3}-t\lambda^{2}+s\lambda-d,\qquad t=\operatorname{tr}A,\quad s=\tfrac12(t^{2}-\operatorname{tr}A^{2}),\quad d=\det A,\;} $$ and its discriminant is $$ \boxed{\;\Delta=t^{2}s^{2}-4s^{3}-4t^{3}d+18tsd-27d^{2}=\prod_{i

The spectral strata have dimensions

Stratum Complex dimension Real dimension
simple spectrum $9$ $18$
double root $8$ $16$
triple root $7$ $14$

A cyclic element has centraliser $\mathbb{C}[A]$ of dimension $3$; it is a torus exactly when the spectrum is simple. The scalar element has centraliser $M_{3}$, of dimension $9$.

At a simple spectrum the Lagrange projectors are the spectral projectors. At a double root the projector of the repeated eigenvalue is the rank-two Dunford projector $(A-bI)/(a-b)$; the individual Lagrange projectors of a splitting have no canonical limit, but their sum tends to the Dunford projector. At a triple root the only spectral projector is $I$, and the nilpotent part is the Jordan decomposition.

Quantity Value for $M_{3}(\mathbb{C})$
Degree of the characteristic polynomial $3$
Degree of the discriminant in the entries $6$
Simple spectrum dimension $9$ complex, $18$ real
Double root dimension $8$ complex, $16$ real
Triple root dimension $7$ complex, $14$ real
Centraliser of a cyclic element $3$
Centraliser of a scalar $9$
Discriminant of $\lambda^{3}-1$ $-27$

Summary of Notation

Symbol Meaning
$\chi_{A}(\lambda)$ the characteristic polynomial $\det(\lambda I-A)$
$t,s,d$ $\operatorname{tr}A$, $\tfrac12(t^{2}-\operatorname{tr}A^{2})$, $\det A$
$\Delta$ the discriminant $\prod_{i
$P_{k}$ a spectral projector, Lagrange at a simple spectrum
$P_{a}$ the Dunford projector of the eigenvalue $a$
$J_{2}(a),J_{3}(a)$ Jordan blocks of size $2$ and $3$ at $a$
$\mathbb{C}[A]$ the algebra generated by $A$, the centraliser of a cyclic element

Further Reading