The Fine Decomposition against the Diagonal at $n=2$

Introduction

Against a complete family of rank-one projections the algebra splits into four lines, one for each pair of indices, and the multiplication of the lines is the multiplication of a two-by-two table.

The article proves the fine decomposition $M_2(\mathbb{C})=\bigoplus_{k,l}A_{kl}$ against the diagonal, computes the dimension of each corner, states the corner multiplication rule, and reads the trace, the determinant and the symmetric half in these coordinates. It assumes The Ideals, the Centre and the Simplicity of $M_2(\mathbb{C})$ for the minimal left ideals, and The Matrix Algebra $M_2(\mathbb{C})$ for the invertibles.

It defers the Peirce operators that produce the same decomposition to The Peirce Basis in $n$ Dimensions, and the frame of the biquaternion algebra to The Peirce Basis of the Biquaternion Algebra. In the biquaternion language the four lines are the four corners $\mathbb{B}_{st}$ of The Peirce Decomposition of the Biquaternion Algebra.

The Complete Family and the Four Projections

Definition. A complete family of idempotents in $M_2(\mathbb{C})$ is a pair $P_{1},P_{2}$ with

$$ P_{k}^{2}=P_{k},\qquad P_{k}P_{l}=0\ (k\neq l),\qquad P_{1}+P_{2}=I . $$

Proposition. A complete family consists of two projections of rank one, so each $P_{k}$ has trace $1$, and the pair is exactly a choice of two complementary lines in $\mathbb{C}^{2}$.

Proof. Taking traces in $P_{1}+P_{2}=I$ gives $\operatorname{tr}P_{1}+\operatorname{tr}P_{2}=2$, and each trace is a nonnegative integer because an idempotent of order two has eigenvalues $0$ or $1$; neither is $0$ since the sum is $I$. The image of $P_{k}$ is a line and the two lines are complementary.

Example. $P_{1}=E_{11}$ and $P_{2}=E_{22}$ is the standard complete family, the one attached to the coordinate lines.

There are as many complete families as there are direct sums $\mathbb{C}^{2}=L_{1}\oplus L_{2}$. That set is the complement of the diagonal in $\mathbb{P}^{1}\times\mathbb{P}^{1}$, an open dense set, and the standard family is one point of it.

The Four Corners

Definition. The corners of a complete family are the spaces

$$ A_{kl}=P_{k}M_2(\mathbb{C})P_{l}=\{P_{k}XP_{l}:X\in M_2(\mathbb{C})\}. $$

Theorem. Each corner is a line: $\dim_{\mathbb{C}}A_{kl}=1$ for all four pairs, the four corners are independent, and their sum is the algebra:

$$ M_2(\mathbb{C})=\bigoplus_{k,l=1}^{2}A_{kl},\qquad \dim_{\mathbb{C}}=1+1+1+1=4 . $$

Proof. The product $P_{k}XP_{l}$ depends only on the composition of the four maps $\mathbb{C}^{2}\to L_{l}\to\mathbb{C}^{2}\to L_{k}$, and the space of maps $L_{l}\to L_{k}$ between two lines is one-dimensional; so each corner is a line, and it is nonzero because $P_{k}P_{l}$ is nonzero when $k=l$. For the sum, every $X$ satisfies $X=\sum_{k,l}P_{k}XP_{l}$ because $\sum_{k}P_{k}=I$; for independence, if $\sum_{k,l}X_{kl}=0$ with $X_{kl}\in A_{kl}$ then multiplying on the left by $P_{m}$ and on the right by $P_{n}$ leaves $X_{mn}=0$.

Corollary (the equality is a refinement). The fine decomposition is a refinement of the split into the two columns: $A_{k1}\oplus A_{k2}$ is the minimal left ideal $M_2P_{k}$ and $A_{1l}\oplus A_{2l}$ is the minimal right ideal $P_{l}M_2$.

Proof. The left multiplication by $P_{k}$ keeps the first index and the right multiplication by $P_{l}$ keeps the second; the space $M_2P_{k}$ consists of the elements whose second index is $k$.

The Fine Decomposition

The coordinates are four scalars. In the standard family every matrix is

$$ A=aE_{11}+bE_{12}+cE_{21}+dE_{22}=\begin{pmatrix}a&b\\ c&d\end{pmatrix}, $$

so the fine decomposition is the decomposition of a matrix into its four entries.

Proposition (the grading). Assign to $A_{kl}$ the degree $(k,l)\in(\mathbb{Z}/2)^{2}$. The product of two homogeneous elements of degrees $\alpha$ and $\beta$ is homogeneous of degree $\alpha+\beta$ when the product is nonzero.

Proof. $A_{kl}A_{lm}\subseteq A_{km}$ because $P_{l}P_{l}=P_{l}$, and $A_{kl}A_{mn}=0$ when $l\neq m$ because $P_{l}P_{m}=0$. So the degree of a product is $(k,m)$, the sum of $(k,l)$ and $(l,m)$ in the group where $1+1=0$ and the indices are read modulo $2$.

Corollary (the grading is fine). The algebra is graded by $(\mathbb{Z}/2)^{2}$ with all four homogeneous components of dimension one, so the grading is fine; at order $n$ the same construction gives a grading by $(\mathbb{Z}/n)^{2}$ with components of dimension one, which is the fine grading of The Peirce Basis in $n$ Dimensions.

The diagonal part and the off-diagonal part. The diagonal corners $A_{11}\oplus A_{22}$ form the subalgebra of matrices diagonal in the frame, isomorphic to $\mathbb{C}\times\mathbb{C}$; the off-diagonal corners $A_{12}\oplus A_{21}$ form a two-dimensional space which is not a subalgebra, since its product lands in the diagonal.

The Multiplication of the Corners

Theorem. The four lines multiply by the rule

$$ A_{kl}A_{lm}\subseteq A_{km},\qquad A_{kl}A_{mn}=0\ \text{when }l\neq m, $$

and the product of two lines filling a chain is onto: $A_{kl}A_{lm}=A_{km}$.

Proof. The inclusions are the proof of the grading. Surjectivity: for nonzero $X\in A_{kl}$ and $Y\in A_{lm}$ the product $XY$ is a nonzero element of the line $A_{km}$, because $X$ maps $L_{l}$ isomorphically onto $L_{k}$ and $Y$ maps $L_{m}$ isomorphically onto $L_{l}$.

Corollary (the system of matrix units). In the standard family the four lines are spanned by $E_{11},E_{12},E_{21},E_{22}$, and the multiplication table is $E_{kl}E_{mn}=\delta_{lm}E_{kn}$.

Proof. $E_{kl}E_{mn}$ sends $e_{n}$ to $e_{l}$ and then to $e_{k}$, which is $\delta_{ln}e_{k}$; the two indices inside must match.

The biquaternion reading. The four lines are the four corners $\mathbb{B}_{++},\mathbb{B}_{+-},\mathbb{B}_{-+},\mathbb{B}_{--}$ of the corpus, each of real dimension $2$ because the biquaternion algebra is over $\mathbb{R}$ and each corner is a complex line read as a real plane. The companion nilpotents $\vec\Upsilon_{+-},\vec\Upsilon_{-+}$ are the two off-diagonal units: that is The Companion Nilpotents of the Biquaternion Algebra.

The Trace and the Determinant in Corner Coordinates

Proposition. In the standard corner coordinates

$$ \operatorname{tr}A=a+d,\qquad \det A=ad-bc . $$

Proof. The trace is the sum of the diagonal entries. For the determinant, expand $\det(A)$ in the entries, or note that $ad-bc$ is the product of the two eigenvalues of the two-by-two matrix, which is the identity of The Elementary Symmetric Functions: $\operatorname{tr}$ and $\det$ in Dimension Two read in these coordinates.

Corollary. The trace is the sum of the two diagonal corners and the determinant is the difference of the two products of diagonal and off-diagonal corners.

Proof. $ad$ is the product of the two diagonal corners and $bc$ the product of the two off-diagonal ones; the determinant is their difference, which is the classical rule of Sarrus at order two.

The adjugate is the corner swap. The adjugate of $A$ is $\begin{pmatrix}d&-b\\ -c&a\end{pmatrix}$, which exchanges the two diagonal corners and negates the two off-diagonal ones.

Corollary. $\operatorname{adj}(A)$ is obtained from $A$ by the involution $\tau_{J}$ of The Involutions of $M_2(\mathbb{C})$ over $\mathbb{R}$ and over $\mathbb{C}$, and $\operatorname{adj}A=A$ exactly for the matrices with $a=d$ and $b=c=0$.

The Diagonal, the Two Halves and the Gauge

The symmetric half meets each corner in a real line. For symmetric $S$ in the standard frame, the corner $A_{11}$ part is $aE_{11}$ with $a$ real and the corner $A_{12}$ part is $bE_{12}$ with $b$ real; so $\operatorname{Sym}_2\cap A_{kl}$ is a real line for each pair.

Proof. The symmetric condition relates the $(1,2)$ and the $(2,1)$ entries and does not mix the diagonal ones, so each corner is cut by one real equation inside its complex line.

Corollary. $\operatorname{Sym}_2$ has real dimension $4$ inside the eight real dimensions, distributed as one real dimension in each of the four corners.

The change of frame is the gauge. Conjugating the family by $g\in\mathrm{GL}_2(\mathbb{C})$ sends $P_{k}$ to $gP_{k}g^{-1}$ and sends the corner $A_{kl}$ to $gA_{kl}g^{-1}$; the decomposition changes but the algebra of the four lines does not.

Proposition. Two complete families are conjugate, and the set of complete families modulo conjugation is a point; the stabiliser of the standard family is the group of diagonal matrices modulo scalars, of dimension $2$.

Proof. Two decompositions of $\mathbb{C}^{2}$ into two ordered lines differ by a linear map taking one pair of lines to the other, and that map is unique up to a map preserving each line, which is diagonal.

The gauge is the rescaling of the frame. The census of the biquaternion frame in The Peirce Basis of the Biquaternion Algebra has one freedom only, the reciprocal rescaling $u\mapsto\lambda u$, $v\mapsto\lambda^{-1}v$; in the matrix language that is the residual diagonal freedom $g=\operatorname{diag}(\lambda,\lambda^{-1})$ modulo the scalars, which is one dimension removed from the two above.

Summary

A complete family of two rank-one projections cuts $M_2(\mathbb{C})$ into four lines $A_{kl}=P_{k}M_2P_{l}$, each of complex dimension one, and the sum is direct. In the standard family the four lines are spanned by $E_{11},E_{12},E_{21},E_{22}$ and the decomposition is the decomposition of a matrix into its four entries.

The product rule is $A_{kl}A_{lm}\subseteq A_{km}$ with the mixed product zero, so the algebra is graded by $(\mathbb{Z}/2)^{2}$ with all components of dimension one. In these coordinates the trace is $a+d$ and the determinant is $ad-bc$; the adjugate exchanges the diagonal corners and negates the off-diagonal ones. The symmetric half meets each corner in a real line, and a change of frame is the conjugation by $g$, with the residual freedom of the diagonal.

Summary of Notation

Symbol Meaning
$P_{1},P_{2}$ a complete family of rank-one projections
$A_{kl}$ the corner $P_{k}M_2P_{l}$, a line
$A_{11}\oplus A_{22}$ the diagonal part, $\cong\mathbb{C}\times\mathbb{C}$
$A_{12}\oplus A_{21}$ the off-diagonal part, not a subalgebra
$E_{kl}$ the matrix units, spanning the standard corners
$a,b,c,d$ the four corner coordinates of a matrix
$(\mathbb{Z}/2)^{2}$ the grading group

Further Reading