The Geometry of the Two Halves at $n=4$, and the Return of the Two-Sided Operators
Introduction
Every geometric object attached to the two halves — the cone in $\operatorname{Herm}_4$, the unitary group as the exponential of $\mathfrak{u}(4)$, the Grassmannians as the idempotents, the contractible symmetric space $\mathrm{GL}_4/U(4)$ with its trace metric — becomes an operator statement once a frame is chosen: the two-sided operators $T_{a,b}$, the sixteen axis-free basis elements, the Segre cone of dimension seven, the length, and the group of order $32$ as the finite skeleton.
The article assembles the geometric picture, then turns it around. The turn is the point of the block: the geometry of the halves is the geometry of the operators in the frame, and each object on the list reappears as a statement about $\operatorname{End}(M_4)$.
It assumes The Positive Cone and Its Boundary at $n=4$, The Space of Idempotents and the Flag Varieties at $n=4$, The Homotopy of $\mathrm{GL}_4(\mathbb{C})$ and of the Two Halves and the four operator articles $\operatorname{End}(M_4(\mathbb{C}))$ as an Algebra, The One-Sided Operators at $n=4$, The Two-Sided Operators and the Segre Cone at $n=4$ and The Length and the Two Ranks at $n=4$. The model at order two is The Geometry of the Two Halves at $n=2$ and the Return of the Two-Sided Operators.
The Hermitian Half and Its Cone
Proposition. $\operatorname{Herm}_4$ is a real vector space of dimension $16$ with a positive definite inner product $\langle A,B\rangle=\operatorname{tr}(AB)$, and the positive definite cone $\operatorname{Herm}_4^{++}$ is an open convex cone in it, homogeneous under congruence by $\mathrm{GL}_4(\mathbb{C})$, self-dual for the inner product.
Proof. The trace of the product of two Hermitian matrices is real and positive definite; the cone properties are established in the article on the cone.
Corollary. The cone carries a Riemannian metric by restriction, and its group of isometries contains the unitary group acting by congruence.
Proof. The inner product restricts to a Riemannian metric on the open submanifold, and unitary congruence preserves the trace of the product.
Corollary. The cone is the set of squares, and the exponential maps the Hermitian half onto it diffeomorphically.
Proof. The spectral theorem.
The boundary. The boundary is stratified by rank with dimensions $15$, $12$, $7$ and $0$, and the faces are indexed by subspaces.
Proof. The rank-stratum dimension $r(8-r)$ and the face description.
The Anti-Hermitian Half and the Lie Algebra
Proposition. $\mathfrak{u}(4)$ is a real Lie algebra of dimension $16$ under the commutator, it is the Lie algebra of $U(4)$, and the exponential maps it onto $U(4)$.
Proof. Closedness under the bracket for anti-Hermitian matrices, the identification of the tangent space at the identity, and the spectral theorem for unitaries.
Corollary. The group $U(4)$ is the compact real form of $\mathrm{GL}_4(\mathbb{C})$ inside the complex group, and its Lie algebra is the fixed set of the conjugation $X\mapsto-X^{\ast}$.
Proof. The unitary condition and its derivative.
Corollary. The two halves are the tangent space and its image at the identity: $\mathfrak{u}(4)=T_{\mathrm I}U(4)$ and $\operatorname{Herm}_4=T_{\mathrm I}\operatorname{Herm}_4^{++}$.
Proof. Both are linear spaces through the identity.
The Idempotents and the Flags
Proposition. The Hermitian idempotents of rank $k$ form the Grassmannian $\mathrm{Gr}_k(\mathbb{C}^{4})=U(4)/(U(k)\times U(4-k))$ of real dimension $2k(4-k)$, inside $\operatorname{Herm}_4$.
Proof. Orthogonal projections are determined by their images.
Corollary. The Grassmannians of ranks one, two, three have real dimensions $6$, $8$, $6$, and the two extreme ranks give points; the full flag has real dimension $12$.
Proof. $2k(4-k)$ and twice the complex dimension $6$ of the full flag.
Corollary. The idempotents are the critical points of the distance function to a point of the cone, so the stratification of the cone and the flag varieties are the same geometry read twice.
Proof. The critical points of the distance to a fixed positive definite matrix are the projections onto its invariant subspaces.
The Symmetric Space $\mathrm{GL}_4/U(4)$
Theorem. $\mathrm{GL}_4(\mathbb{C})/U(4)$ is a symmetric space of noncompact type, diffeomorphic to $\operatorname{Herm}_4^{++}$, hence contractible, of real dimension $16$.
Proof. The polar decomposition identifies the quotient with the cone; the cone is convex; the Cartan involution $\theta(X)=-X^{\ast}$ has fixed set $\mathfrak{u}(4)$ and $(-1)$-eigenspace $\operatorname{Herm}_4$, which is the model of the tangent space of the quotient.
Corollary. The trace metric $\langle X,Y\rangle=\operatorname{tr}(XY)$ on the tangent space is invariant under the group, and the geodesics are $t\mapsto A^{1/2}e^{tX}A^{1/2}$ for $A$ in the cone and $X$ Hermitian traceless in the appropriate normalisation.
Proof. The invariant metric on a symmetric space and the exponential map of the cone.
Corollary. The curvature is nonpositive, and the space is a manifold of noncompact type with no closed geodesics.
Proof. The sectional curvature of a symmetric space of noncompact type is nonpositive, and a nonpositively curved complete simply connected manifold has no closed geodesics.
The compact dual. The compact dual of $\mathrm{GL}_4(\mathbb{C})/U(4)$ is the group manifold $U(4)$ read as the symmetric space $(U(4)\times U(4))/\Delta U(4)$.
Proof. The Cartan decomposition of the group case, with the involution $\theta(g)=g^{-\ast}$ whose fixed set is the unitary group; the dual replaces $\operatorname{Herm}_4$ by $i\operatorname{Herm}_4$ and the noncompact group by the compact one.
Corollary. The geometry of the halves has two faces: a contractible noncompact one and a compact one obtained by replacing the Hermitian cone by its compact section.
Proof. The duality.
The Return to the Operators
Proposition. A choice of frame carries each of these geometric objects to a statement about the two-sided operators. The element algebra $\mathbb{B}$ of dimension $4$ sits inside $\operatorname{End}(\mathbb{B})$ of dimension $16$ as the two families $\mathbb{B}_L$ and $\mathbb{B}_R$, and the two-sided products $T_{a,b}=L_aR_b$ are the sixteen-dimensional coordinate system of the operator space.
Proof. The product of a left and a right multiplication and the independence of the sixteen products.
Corollary. The cone and the idempotents become statements about the coefficient matrix: positivity becomes the constraint that the coefficient vector lies in the Hermitian direction, and the flags become the rank conditions on the mixed blocks.
Proof. The reading of an element in the axis-free coordinates and the Peirce blocks.
Corollary. The sixteen axis-free basis elements are signed permutations of determinant one, they are orthonormal up to the factor four for the Hilbert–Schmidt form, and their trace pairing takes the values $\pm4$ with ten plus signs and six minus signs.
Proof. The verified computation of the pairing on the axis-free basis.
Corollary. The ten and the six are the trace-form inertia, and they coincide with the symmetric and antisymmetric directions, so the geometry of the halves is the inertia of a single quadratic form on the operator basis.
Proof. The set equality between the $+4$ elements and the symmetric ones.
The operators in order. The operator algebra of dimension $256$ contains the algebra of dimension $16$ as the two families of one-sided operators; the two-sided products give the Segre cone of dimension seven; the length of an operator is the rank of its coefficient matrix; and the group of order $32$ generated by the signed basis elements is the finite skeleton of the whole picture.
Proof. The four operator articles of the block.
Corollary. The geometry of the halves is not a different subject: it is the geometry of the operator algebra restricted to the rank-one part, read in the axis-free frame.
Proof. The identifications above.
Summary
The Hermitian half is a real space of dimension sixteen carrying the open convex self-dual cone; the anti-Hermitian half is the Lie algebra of the unitary group; the Hermitian idempotents of rank $k$ are the Grassmannians inside the Hermitian half, of real dimension $2k(4-k)$, and the cone is stratified by the same flags.
$\mathrm{GL}_4/U(4)$ is a symmetric space of noncompact type of dimension sixteen, contractible, with nonpositive curvature and the invariant trace metric; its compact dual replaces the cone by the compact section.
The return is the point: with a frame chosen, each object becomes an operator statement. The two-sided products give the sixteen coordinates, the signed permutations give the finite skeleton of order $32$, the trace pairing gives the inertia $(10,6)$, the Segre cone gives the rank-one part, and the length measures the coefficient matrix. The geometry of the halves is the geometry of the operator algebra read on the rank-one cone.
Summary of Notation
| Symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
| $\operatorname{Herm}_4^{++}$ | the self-dual cone of dimension $16$ |
| $\mathfrak{u}(4)$ | the Lie algebra of $U(4)$ |
| $\mathrm{Gr}_k=U(4)/(U(k)\times U(4-k))$ | the Hermitian idempotents |
| $\mathrm{GL}_4/U(4)$ | the contractible symmetric space |
| $T_{a,b}=L_aR_b$ | the two-sided operator |
| $(10,6)$ | the inertia of the trace form |
Further Reading
- Sigurdur Helgason, Differential Geometry, Lie Groups and Symmetric Spaces (AMS, 2001), for symmetric spaces of noncompact type and their compact duals.
- The Positive Cone and Its Boundary at $n=4$, for the cone and its faces.
- The Space of Idempotents and the Flag Varieties at $n=4$, for the Grassmannians.
- The Two-Sided Operators and the Segre Cone at $n=4$, for the operator side of the return.
- The Length and the Two Ranks at $n=4$, for the coefficient matrix and its rank.
- The Geometry of the Two Halves at $n=2$ and the Return of the Two-Sided Operators, for the case at order two.