The Minimal Left Ideals of the Biquaternion Algebra

Introduction

An idempotent $\tilde\Pi$ cuts the algebra into $\mathbb{B}=\mathbb{B}\tilde\Pi\oplus\mathbb{B}(e_t-\tilde\Pi)$, and the two summands are left ideals. For the biquaternion algebra the idempotents come in a sphere of pairs, one pair for each unit real axis $\vec u$, and each of the two summands is as small as a left ideal can be: it contains no nonzero proper left subideal.

This article defines the idempotents at an axis, computes the two ideals they generate, proves minimality, gives the decomposition $\mathbb{B}=S_{+}\oplus S_{-}$, describes the lattice of left ideals, and draws the consequence that matters for the carriers: because the algebra is simple, a carrier of the multiplication is necessarily one-sided, and the two-sided ideals are the two trivial ones.

The idempotents themselves, their classes and their Peirce decompositions are The Square Roots of One and the Idempotents of the Biquaternion Algebra, Peirce Decompositions of the Biquaternion Algebra and The Peirce Basis of a Peirce Decomposition of the Biquaternion Algebra; the nilpotent that accompanies each ideal is The Companion Nilpotents of the Biquaternion Algebra; the module category is The Category of Modules in the Biquaternion Algebra; and the carrier these ideals define is From the Spin to the Carriers and the Closures.

Nothing below is a statement of physics. The elements are written $\tilde Q$ with coefficients $Q_t,Q_x,Q_y,Q_z$, the axis $\vec u$ is a unit real vector, and $\vec e_x,\vec e_y,\vec e_z$ are the pure quaternion units.

The Idempotents at an Axis

Definition. For a unit real vector $\vec u$ put

$$ \tilde\Pi_{\pm}(\vec u)=\tfrac12\bigl(e_t\pm i\vec u\bigr). $$

Proposition (the four relations). The two elements are idempotents, they are orthogonal and complementary:

$$ \tilde\Pi_{\pm}^{2}=\tilde\Pi_{\pm},\qquad \tilde\Pi_{+}\tilde\Pi_{-}=\tilde\Pi_{-}\tilde\Pi_{+}=0,\qquad \tilde\Pi_{+}+\tilde\Pi_{-}=e_t . $$

Proof. $(\vec u)^{2}=-e_t$ for a unit real vector, so $(i\vec u)^{2}=e_t$ and $\tilde\Pi_{\pm}^{2}=\tfrac14(e_t\pm2i\vec u+e_t)=\tfrac12(e_t\pm i\vec u)=\tilde\Pi_{\pm}$. The products are $\tfrac14(e_t-(i\vec u)^{2})=\tfrac14(e_t-e_t)=0$, and the sum is $e_t$.

Proposition (the conjugate idempotent). $\tilde\Pi_{\pm}(\vec u)^{*}=\tilde\Pi_{\mp}(\vec u)$; the two idempotents of a pair are exchanged by the Hermitian conjugation, and neither is Hermitian at a real axis.

Proof. ${}^{*}$ fixes $e_t$ and reverses $i\vec u$, so $\tilde\Pi_{+}^{*}=\tfrac12(e_t-i\vec u)=\tilde\Pi_{-}$; an idempotent is Hermitian only if it equals its conjugate, which would force $\vec u=0$, and no idempotent of the algebra is Hermitian at a real axis.

Remark (the axis is a parameter). The pair is indexed by the sphere of unit real axes, a two-sphere, and no point of it is preferred by the algebra. Under $Q\mapsto uQu^{*}$ with $u$ a unit real quaternion the axis rotates, so the unitary group acts on the family of pairs transitively; the pair at $\vec e_z$ is the model, and every other pair is its conjugate.

Example (the model pair). At $\vec u=\vec e_z$,

$$ \tilde\Pi_{+}(\vec e_z)=\tfrac12(e_t+i\vec e_z)=\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\0&0\end{pmatrix},\qquad \tilde\Pi_{-}(\vec e_z)=\tfrac12(e_t-i\vec e_z)=\begin{pmatrix}0&0\\0&1\end{pmatrix}, $$

in the $M_2(\mathbb{C})$ Pauli representation, with $e_t$ the identity and $\vec e_k=-i\sigma_k$.

The Two Ideals

Definition. The left ideal at the axis is

$$ S_{\pm}(\vec u)=\mathbb{B}\,\tilde\Pi_{\pm}(\vec u)=\{\tilde Q\tilde\Pi_{\pm}(\vec u) : \tilde Q\in\mathbb{B}\}. $$

Proposition (ideal, dimension, basis). $S_{\pm}$ is a left ideal of $\mathbb{B}$, of real dimension $4$ and complex dimension $2$, with $\mathbb{C}$-basis

$$ S_{+}=\operatorname{span}_{\mathbb{C}}\bigl\{\tilde\Pi_{+},\ \vec\Upsilon_{-+}\bigr\},\qquad S_{-}=\operatorname{span}_{\mathbb{C}}\bigl\{\tilde\Pi_{-},\ \vec\Upsilon_{+-}\bigr\}, $$

where

$$ \vec\Upsilon_{-+}(\vec u)=\tfrac12\bigl(i\vec a+\vec b\bigr),\qquad \vec\Upsilon_{+-}(\vec u)=\tfrac12\bigl(i\vec a-\vec b\bigr) $$

for unit real vectors $\vec a,\vec b$ that complete $\vec u$ to a right-handed orthonormal triple.

Proof. The set is a left ideal because $X(Y\tilde\Pi_{\pm})=(XY)\tilde\Pi_{\pm}$. At the axis $\vec u=\vec e_z$, with $\vec a=\vec e_x$ and $\vec b=\vec e_y$, the four products of the basis elements with $\tilde\Pi_{+}$ are

$$ e_t\tilde\Pi_{+}=\tilde\Pi_{+},\qquad \vec e_x\tilde\Pi_{+}=-i\vec\Upsilon_{-+},\qquad \vec e_y\tilde\Pi_{+}=\vec\Upsilon_{-+},\qquad \vec e_z\tilde\Pi_{+}=-i\tilde\Pi_{+}, $$

so the four real spanning vectors lie in the complex span of $\tilde\Pi_{+}$ and $\vec\Upsilon_{-+}$, which is therefore the whole ideal and has complex dimension $2$. The general axis follows by the transitivity of the conjugation by the unit real quaternions, and the same computation with $\tilde\Pi_{-}$ gives $S_{-}$.

Example (the model ideals). At $\vec u=\vec e_z$,

$$ S_{+}=\left\{\begin{pmatrix}a&0\\c&0\end{pmatrix}\right\},\qquad S_{-}=\left\{\begin{pmatrix}0&b\\0&d\end{pmatrix}\right\}, $$

the first-column and the second-column matrices. Each is a two-dimensional complex space, four real dimensions, and each is closed under left multiplication by every biquaternion.

Minimality

Theorem (the two ideals are minimal). $S_{\pm}$ has no left subideal other than $0$ and $S_{\pm}$.

Proof. In the matrix model, $S_{+}$ is the space of matrices whose image is the first coordinate axis; a left ideal of $M_2(\mathbb{C})$ is a set of matrices whose images lie in a fixed subspace $W\subseteq\mathbb{C}^2$, and the left ideals contained in $S_{+}$ correspond to the subspaces $W$ of the line $\mathbb{C}e_1$, of which there are two: $0$ and the line itself. The same argument on the second axis gives $S_{-}$. Intrinsically: if $0\neq s\in S_{\pm}$ then $\mathbb{B}s$ is a nonzero left ideal contained in $S_{\pm}$, and in the model $\mathbb{B}s$ is the whole column space because $M_2(\mathbb{C})s=\mathbb{C}^2$ for $s\neq 0$.

Corollary (every nonzero element is a generator). For $0\neq s\in S_{\pm}$ one has $\mathbb{B}s=S_{\pm}$; the ideal is generated by any one of its nonzero elements.

Remark (what minimality excludes). A left ideal strictly between $0$ and $S_{\pm}$ would be a left submodule, and a carrier of the multiplication is by definition irreducible; minimality is exactly the statement that $S_{\pm}$ qualifies. Nothing smaller than two complex dimensions can be a left ideal, since a line $\mathbb{C}s$ is a left ideal only if $\mathbb{B}s\subseteq\mathbb{C}s$, which fails for every nonzero $s$.

Remark (the dimension is not an accident). The complex dimension $2$ is the dimension of the simple module, and it is forced: an algebra of the form $M_n(\mathbb{C})$ has simple modules of dimension $n$, and $n=2$ here because the biquaternion algebra is a full $2\times2$ matrix algebra.

The Decomposition of the Algebra

Theorem. $\mathbb{B}=S_{+}\oplus S_{-}$ as left $\mathbb{B}$-modules.

Proof. The two idempotents are orthogonal and sum to the unit, so every $\tilde Q$ decomposes as $\tilde Q=\tilde Q\tilde\Pi_{+}+\tilde Q\tilde\Pi_{-}$; the sum is direct because an element of both ideals is annihilated by both idempotents and hence is zero, $\tilde Q=\tilde Q e_t=\tilde Q(\tilde\Pi_{+}+\tilde\Pi_{-})=0$.

Corollary (dimensions). $4+4=8$ over $\mathbb{R}$ and $2+2=4$ over $\mathbb{C}$; the two summands have equal dimension, and the decomposition is a splitting of the regular module into two copies of one simple module.

Remark (the two copies are isomorphic, not equal). $S_{+}$ and $S_{-}$ are isomorphic as left modules: right multiplication by the companion nilpotent $\vec\Upsilon_{+-}$ carries $S_{+}$ into $S_{-}$, it does not vanish, and a nonzero map of simple modules is an isomorphism. The two remain distinct subspaces of the same algebra. The Companion Nilpotents of the Biquaternion Algebra gives the maps explicitly.

The Lattice of Left Ideals

Theorem (the left ideals). The left ideals of $\mathbb{B}$ are exactly the sets

$$ I_W=\{\tilde Q : \tilde Q(\mathbb{C}^2)\subseteq W\} $$

for the subspaces $W\subseteq\mathbb{C}^2$ in the defining module, and the lattice of left ideals is the lattice of subspaces of a two-dimensional complex space: $0$, two families of lines, and $\mathbb{B}$.

Proof. In the matrix model a left ideal $I$ is a subspace of $M_2(\mathbb{C})$ closed under left multiplication; the condition $MI\subseteq I$ for all $M$ forces $I=\{M : M(\mathbb{C}^2)\subseteq W\}$ with $W=\bigcup_{M\in I}M(\mathbb{C}^2)$, which is a subspace; conversely such a set is a left ideal. The subspaces of $\mathbb{C}^2$ are $0$, the lines and the plane, and the lines form a projective line.

Corollary (three kinds). The left ideals are $0$; the minimal ones, the two columns at a chosen axis together with all their conjugates; and $\mathbb{B}$. The minimal ones are the carriers.

Remark (the lattice is not a chain). There are two minimal ideals and they are incomparable, so the lattice is not a chain: the sum $S_{+}+S_{-}$ is already $\mathbb{B}$, and the intersection is $0$. A left ideal is never strictly between a minimal one and the algebra.

Simplicity and the One-Sidedness

Theorem. $\mathbb{B}$ is simple: its only two-sided ideals are $0$ and $\mathbb{B}$.

Proof. Introduction to the Algebra of Biquaternions, §Simplicity: a nonzero two-sided ideal contains a nonzero element, and multiplying by the invertibles and taking linear combinations produces the whole algebra; equivalently $\mathbb{B}\cong M_2(\mathbb{C})$ is a full matrix algebra over a field, which is simple.

Corollary (a carrier of the multiplication is one-sided). No two-sided ideal other than $0$ and $\mathbb{B}$ exists, so an irreducible left ideal is a carrier and the algebra itself is not one. The two-sided structure is exhausted by the trivial pair, and every carrier of the multiplication is a minimal left ideal.

Corollary (the algebra is the sum of its carriers). $\mathbb{B}=S_{+}\oplus S_{-}$ is a direct sum of two carriers, and it is not itself a carrier because it is reducible. The carrier is a summand, never the whole.

Remark (why a two-sided carrier cannot exist). A two-sided ideal is at the same time a left and a right ideal; the two-sided ideals are $0$ and $\mathbb{B}$, and both are excluded — $0$ is not a carrier by definition, and $\mathbb{B}$ is reducible. The reason the count of carriers is finite and small is the simplicity of the algebra together with the shortness of the lattice of left ideals.

The Sphere of Axes and the Type

Proposition (transitivity). The group of unit real quaternions acts transitively on the pairs $\bigl(\tilde\Pi_{+}(\vec u),\tilde\Pi_{-}(\vec u)\bigr)$, and it carries $S_{+}(\vec u)$ to $S_{+}(\vec u')$ for a suitable rotation of the axis.

Proof. A unit real quaternion $\tilde q$ acts by $Q\mapsto\tilde qQ\tilde q^{*}$, which rotates $\vec u$ to $\vec u'$; the idempotent $\tilde\Pi_{+}(\vec u)=\tfrac12(e_t+i\vec u)$ is carried to $\tfrac12(e_t+i\vec u')$, and the ideal generated by it to the ideal generated by its image. The action of the unit quaternions on the axes is the standard transitive action on the two-sphere, with stabiliser the circle about the axis.

Corollary (one type, many subspaces). All the minimal left ideals have the same type, of complex dimension $2$; the axis is a parameter of the family and not a datum of the algebra. The type is what a carrier contributes to the count, and it does not depend on the axis.

Remark (the axis and the weight). The axis does affect the weight string of a generator: the generator $\tilde S(\vec u)$ is the one that is diagonal on the ideal at the axis $\vec u$, and a generator at another axis has a different matrix in the same basis. From the Spin to the Carriers and the Closures, §The Spinor Plane, reads the string at the axis of the ideal, where it is $\{+\tfrac12,-\tfrac12\}$.

Summary

For each unit real axis $\vec u$ the element $\tilde\Pi_{\pm}(\vec u)=\tfrac12(e_t\pm i\vec u)$ is an idempotent, the two are orthogonal and sum to the unit, and they generate the two left ideals $S_{\pm}=\mathbb{B}\tilde\Pi_{\pm}$.

Each ideal is four real-dimensional and two complex-dimensional, with basis $\{\tilde\Pi_{\pm},\vec\Upsilon_{\mp\pm}\}$, and it is minimal: any nonzero element of it generates it, and no left ideal lies strictly between $0$ and it. In the matrix model the two ideals are the two columns.

The algebra splits as $\mathbb{B}=S_{+}\oplus S_{-}$ into two copies of one simple module, the left ideals form the lattice of subspaces of a two-dimensional complex space, and the algebra is simple, so its only two-sided ideals are the two trivial ones. Hence a carrier of the multiplication is one-sided, the algebra itself is never a carrier, and the family of carriers is one type over a sphere of axes.

Summary of Notation

symbol meaning
$\tilde\Pi_{\pm}(\vec u)=\tfrac12(e_t\pm i\vec u)$ the complementary idempotents at the axis $\vec u$
$S_{\pm}(\vec u)=\mathbb{B}\tilde\Pi_{\pm}(\vec u)$ the minimal left ideals
$\vec\Upsilon_{-+},\vec\Upsilon_{+-}$ the companion nilpotents, the second basis vector of each ideal
$I_W$ the left ideal of the matrices whose image lies in $W$
$\mathbb{C}^2$ the defining module, the type of the two ideals
simple algebra an algebra whose only two-sided ideals are $0$ and the algebra
minimal left ideal a left ideal with no left subideal other than $0$ and itself

Further Reading