The Peirce Decomposition of $\operatorname{Sym}_2$ as a Jordan Algebra

Introduction

The symmetric half with the Jordan product $x\circ y=\tfrac12(xy+yx)$ splits at a symmetric idempotent into three Peirce spaces $V_{2}$, $V_{1}$, $V_{0}$ of dimension one each, and the Jordan product obeys the rule $V_{i}\circ V_{j}\subseteq V_{i+j}$.

The article defines the Jordan product on the symmetric half, identifies the Jordan multiplication by an idempotent with a projection whose eigenvalues are $1$, $\tfrac12$, $0$, computes the three dimensions, proves the Peirce rules, checks the Jordan identity, and compares the three-piece decomposition with the four-piece associative one. It assumes The Jordan Algebra $\operatorname{Sym}_2$, The Peirce Decomposition in Two Dimensions and The Peirce Basis and the Corners at $n=2$.

It defers the Hermitian idempotents and their sphere to The Spectral Theorem: the Hermitian Case and the Sphere of Idempotents, and the corner recursion to The Peirce Decomposition and the Corner Recursion of $M_2(\mathbb{C})$.

The Jordan Product on the Symmetric Half

Definition. The Jordan product of two matrices is $x\circ y=\tfrac12(xy+yx)$.

Proposition. The symmetric half is closed under the Jordan product, and the product is commutative but not associative.

Proof. The transpose of $\tfrac12(xy+yx)$ is $\tfrac12(y^{\mathsf T}x^{\mathsf T}+x^{\mathsf T}y^{\mathsf T})=\tfrac12(yx+xy)$ for symmetric $x$ and $y$, so the product stays symmetric; commutativity is the symmetry of the display; and the failure of associativity is the failure of the associative product in the symmetrised form.

Corollary. The symmetrised product of two symmetric matrices is $\tfrac12(xy+yx)$, which differs from $xy$ exactly when the two factors do not commute.

Proof. For commuting symmetric matrices $xy$ is symmetric and the symmetrisation is the product itself; otherwise $xy$ is not symmetric and the symmetrisation is a different matrix.

The Multiplication by an Idempotent

Definition. The Jordan multiplication by an element $a$ is the operator $L_{a}(x)=a\circ x$.

Proposition. For a symmetric idempotent $e$ the operator $L_{e}$ is diagonalisable, with the eigenvalues $1$, $\tfrac12$ and $0$.

Proof. At the standard frame $e=E_{11}$ the three elements $e$, $w=E_{12}+E_{21}$ and $f=E_{22}$ form a basis of the symmetric half, and $e\circ e=e$, $e\circ w=\tfrac12 w$, $e\circ f=0$. A linear operator is determined by its values on a basis, so the matrix of $L_{e}$ in this basis is $\operatorname{diag}(1,\tfrac12,0)$.

Corollary. The symmetric half splits as the direct sum of the three eigenspaces $V_{2}$, $V_{1}$, $V_{0}$ of $L_{e}$, of dimension one each at the standard frame.

Proof. The operator is diagonal in the basis displayed, with three distinct eigenvalues, so the three eigenspaces are the three lines of the basis.

Definition. The Peirce spaces of the Jordan algebra are

$$ V_{2}=\{x: e\circ x=x\},\qquad V_{1}=\Bigl\{x: e\circ x=\tfrac12 x\Bigr\},\qquad V_{0}=\{x: e\circ x=0\}. $$

Corollary. At the standard frame $V_{2}$ is the line of $e$, $V_{0}$ is the line of $f$, and $V_{1}$ is the line of $w=E_{12}+E_{21}$.

Proof. The three lines are the eigenspaces computed above, with the eigenvalues $1$, $0$ and $\tfrac12$.

Corollary. The Jordan splitting merges the two mixed corners: $V_{2}=A_{11}$, $V_{0}=A_{00}$, and $V_{1}$ is the symmetrisation of $A_{12}$ and $A_{21}$.

Proof. The diagonal corners are the eigenspaces of the eigenvalue $1$ and $0$, and the mixed corners are both mapped by the symmetrisation onto the line of $w$.

The Dimensions

Theorem. For a symmetric rank-one idempotent the three Peirce spaces have dimension one each, and the dimensions sum to three, the dimension of the symmetric half.

Proof. At $e=E_{11}$ the symmetric half has the basis $E_{11}$, $E_{12}+E_{21}$, $E_{22}$; the first is $V_{2}$, the third is $V_{0}$, and the middle one satisfies $e\circ(E_{12}+E_{21})=\tfrac12(E_{12}+E_{21})$, so it spans $V_{1}$.

Corollary. The symmetric idempotent of rank one gives the finest Jordan splitting, and the antisymmetric part does not appear at all.

Proof. The symmetric half has dimension three and the three spaces have dimension one each, so no space can be further split; and the antisymmetric line is not contained in the symmetric half.

Corollary. At the two trivial idempotents $0$ and $I$ the splitting degenerates to the whole space in one piece.

Proof. $L_{0}$ is zero and $L_{I}$ is the identity on the symmetric half, so the only nonzero eigenspace is $V_{0}$ in the first case and $V_{2}$ in the second.

The Peirce Rules

Theorem. The Jordan Peirce spaces satisfy

$$ V_{2}\circ V_{2}\subseteq V_{2},\quad V_{2}\circ V_{1}\subseteq V_{1},\quad V_{2}\circ V_{0}=0,\quad V_{1}\circ V_{1}\subseteq V_{2}\oplus V_{0},\quad V_{1}\circ V_{0}\subseteq V_{1},\quad V_{0}\circ V_{0}\subseteq V_{0}. $$

Proof. Read the six products in the basis $e$, $w$, $f$ of the standard frame, where $e\circ e=e$, $e\circ w=\tfrac12 w$, $e\circ f=0$, $w\circ w=I=e+f$, $w\circ f=\tfrac12 w$ and $f\circ f=f$. Each product lands in the space named by the two eigenvalues, and the middle product $w\circ w$ is the only one that needs both diagonal pieces.

Corollary. The single departure from the sum rule is $V_{1}\circ V_{1}\subseteq V_{2}\oplus V_{0}$, whose second summand is the price of the identity element.

Proof. At the standard frame the product of $w$ with itself is the identity, half of which is $e$ in $V_{2}$ and half $f$ in $V_{0}$.

Corollary. $V_{2}\circ V_{0}=0$ and $V_{1}\circ V_{1}=\mathbb{C}I$, so the product of the two diagonal eigenspaces vanishes and the square of the middle space is the line of the identity.

Proof. The first is the vanishing of $e\circ f$, and the second is $w\circ w=I$ with $w$ spanning $V_{1}$.

The Jordan Identity

Proposition. The product satisfies the Jordan identity

$$ (x\circ y)\circ(x\circ x)=x\circ\bigl(y\circ(x\circ x)\bigr) $$

for all symmetric $x$ and $y$.

Proof. The identity is the linearisation of the associativity of the powers in the symmetrised product, and it is checked directly on the three-dimensional space, where every product is a polynomial identity in the entries.

Corollary. The symmetric half with the Jordan product is a Jordan algebra of dimension three, and it is special: it comes from the associative algebra by symmetrisation.

Proof. The product is the symmetrisation of the associative product of the ambient algebra, so the Jordan algebra is special by construction; and its dimension is three.

Corollary. The trace form restricts to a positive definite form on the symmetric half, which is the trace form of the Jordan algebra.

Proof. The restriction of $\operatorname{tr}(xy)$ to the symmetric half is positive definite with the eigenvalues $1,1,2$ in the Pauli basis, as computed in The Two Halves as Orthogonal Complements at $n=2$.

The Comparison with the Associative Splitting

Proposition. The associative Peirce decomposition has four pieces and the Jordan decomposition has three: the two mixed corners merge.

Proof. The associative decomposition separates $A_{12}$ from $A_{21}$ by the right multiplication, which distinguishes left from right; the Jordan product is commutative and cannot tell the two apart, so their symmetrisation is a single space.

Corollary. The dimension count is $1+1+1+1=4$ for the associative algebra and $1+1+1=3$ for the symmetric half, and the difference is the antisymmetric line.

Proof. The two mixed corners contribute two dimensions in the algebra and one in the symmetric half, and the antisymmetric line accounts for the remaining difference.

Corollary. The Jordan Peirce space $V_{1}$ is the graph of the identity map between the two mixed corners under the symmetrisation.

Proof. An element of $V_{1}$ is the symmetrisation of an element of $A_{12}$ and an element of $A_{21}$, and at the standard frame the representative is $E_{12}+E_{21}$.

Summary

The symmetric half with the Jordan product $x\circ y=\tfrac12(xy+yx)$ is a Jordan algebra of dimension three. A symmetric rank-one idempotent $e$ gives the operator $L_{e}$ with the eigenvalues $1$, $\tfrac12$, $0$, and the three Peirce spaces $V_{2}$, $V_{1}$, $V_{0}$ of dimension one each, spanned at the standard frame by $E_{11}$, $E_{12}+E_{21}$, $E_{22}$.

The Peirce rules hold, with $V_{1}\circ V_{1}\subseteq V_{2}\oplus V_{0}$ the single departure from the sum rule and $V_{2}\circ V_{0}=0$, the Jordan identity holds, and the Jordan splitting is the associative four-piece splitting with the two mixed corners merged, since the commutative product cannot separate left from right.

Summary of Notation

Symbol Meaning
$x\circ y$ $\tfrac12(xy+yx)$, the Jordan product
$L_{a}$ Jordan multiplication by $a$
$V_{2},V_{1},V_{0}$ the three Jordan Peirce spaces
$e$ a symmetric rank-one idempotent
$w$ $E_{12}+E_{21}$, the off-diagonal element

Further Reading