The Rotor as a Square Root of a Rotation: the Two Signs and the Double Cover

Introduction

Every rotation at order two has exactly two square roots in the rotation group, the rotors $+e^{tJ/2}$ and $-e^{tJ/2}$, so the squaring map of the circle onto itself is a double cover and the rotor is defined only up to sign.

The article proves that a rotation has two rotation square roots and no more, computes them from the half angle, describes the squaring map as a covering of degree two with the antipodal deck transformation, shows that a full turn of the rotor returns minus the starting rotor, and reads the same two signs inside $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ where the conjugation action covers the rotations of three-space. It assumes The Exponential of $\operatorname{Skew}_2$: the Single Rotation Plane, The Lie Algebra $\operatorname{Skew}_2$: One Dimension, Hence Abelian and Normal $2\times2$ Matrices and the Common Spectral Theorem.

It follows the corpus article The Polar Decomposition of a Biquaternion for the rotor read as a biquaternion of unit length.

Square Roots inside the Circle

A rotation at order two is a point of the circle, and its square roots are the two points at half the angle and at half the angle plus a half turn.

Proposition. Let $R=e^{tJ}$ be a rotation. Then $A=e^{tJ/2}$ satisfies $A^{2}=R$, and so does $-A$.

Proof. The powers add: $e^{tJ/2}e^{tJ/2}=e^{tJ}$ because both factors are polynomials in $J$; and $(-A)^{2}=A^{2}$ because the two signs multiply to one.

Corollary. The two square roots are antipodal points of the circle, and their product is $-I$.

Proof. The two roots differ by the sign, and $A\cdot(-A)=-A^{2}=-R$; at the level of the circle the sign is the half turn, which is the antipodal map.

Corollary. The two roots are rotations, so the square root of a rotation is again a rotation at order two.

Proof. Each is $e^{tJ/2}$ or its negative, and both are orthogonal with determinant one.

The Two Signs

The sign of the rotor is not an artefact of the formula: it is the ambiguity of the square root.

Proposition. If $A$ is a rotation and $A^{2}=R$, then $A=\pm e^{tJ/2}$.

Proof. A rotation $A$ commutes with $R$; when $t$ is not a multiple of $\pi$ the commutant of $R$ is the two-dimensional algebra spanned by $I$ and $J$, so $A=aI+bJ$ with real $a,b$. Then $A^{2}=(a^{2}-b^{2})I+2abJ$ because $J^{2}=-I$, and matching with $R=\cos t\,I+\sin t\,J$ gives $(a+ib)^{2}=e^{it}$, hence $a+ib=\pm e^{it/2}$ and $A=\pm e^{tJ/2}$. When $R=\pm I$ the same computation with the Euler formula gives the two roots $\pm I$ or $\pm J$, so in every case there are exactly two.

Corollary. The squaring map on the rotation group is exactly two-to-one, so the two signs are the whole ambiguity.

Proof. Every rotation has at least the two roots displayed, and the proposition shows that there are no others.

Corollary. The squaring map is smooth and its derivative never vanishes, so it is a local diffeomorphism.

Proof. In the angle coordinate the map is $t\mapsto 2t$ modulo $2\pi$, whose derivative is the constant two, so no derivative vanishes.

The Double Cover

Theorem. The squaring map $R\mapsto R^{2}$ from the circle to itself is a covering of degree two, with deck transformation the antipodal map $R\mapsto-R$.

Proof. The map is two-to-one by the previous section, it is a local diffeomorphism, and the two points over a rotation are exchanged by the negation, which is a free involution of the circle.

Corollary. The circle is the total space of a double cover of itself, and the quotient by the antipodal map is again a circle.

Proof. The quotient of a circle by the antipodal involution is a circle, and the projection is the squaring map.

Corollary. The fundamental group of the circle has order two, and the double cover corresponds to the subgroup of index two.

Proof. The cover is connected and of degree two, so the subgroup is of index two in $\mathbb{Z}$, and the only such subgroup is the even integers.

The Rotor of an Angle

Proposition. The rotor of the rotation by the angle $t$ is $\pm\bigl(\cos\tfrac{t}{2}\,I+\sin\tfrac{t}{2}\,J\bigr)$, and it turns by half the angle of the rotation.

Proof. The Euler formula at the half angle gives $e^{(t/2)J}=\cos\tfrac{t}{2}I+\sin\tfrac{t}{2}J$, and its square is the Euler formula at the angle $t$.

Corollary. A rotation by a full turn has the rotors $\pm I$, and a rotation by a half turn has the rotors $\pm J$.

Proof. At $t=2\pi$ the half angle is $\pi$ and the rotor is $-I$ or $I$; at $t=\pi$ the half angle is $\pi/2$ and the rotor is $J$ or $-J$.

Corollary. The trace of the rotor is $2\cos\tfrac{t}{2}$, so the rotor distinguishes the angle $t$ from $t+2\pi$ by a sign.

Proof. The trace is twice the cosine of the half angle, and adding a full turn to $t$ changes the half angle by $\pi$, which changes the cosine to its negative.

A Full Turn of the Rotor

Theorem. Continuous rotation of the rotor through a full turn returns minus the rotor, and only a turn of two full turns returns the rotor itself.

Proof. The path $s\mapsto e^{sJ/2}$ for $s$ from $0$ to $2\pi$ starts at $I$ and ends at $-I$, and it is a lift of a full turn of the rotation; a further full turn returns to $I$.

Corollary. The rotor is not a function of the rotation alone, and a physical rotation through $360$ degrees changes the sign of the rotor.

Proof. The two ends of the path are different matrices with the same square, so the assignment of a rotor to a rotation is not a continuous single-valued choice along the whole circle.

Corollary. A continuous choice of a rotor is possible on any interval of angles of length less than a full turn, and not on the whole circle.

Proof. On such an interval the half angle varies over an interval of length less than $\pi$, so the rotor stays away from the antipodal point and the choice is continuous; on the whole circle the two ends disagree.

The Same Signs in $\mathrm{SU}(2)$

Proposition. The matrices $\pm e^{i\theta(\vec n\cdot\vec\sigma)/2}$ are unitary with determinant one, and they are the two elements of $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ with the same conjugation action.

Proof. The matrix $i\theta(\vec n\cdot\vec\sigma)/2$ is anti-Hermitian and traceless, so its exponential is unitary with determinant one; and the sign does not change the conjugation, since $(-q)X(-q)^{*}=qXq^{*}$.

Corollary. The conjugation action of $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ on the traceless Hermitian matrices depends only on the class of the rotor up to sign.

Proof. The action is invariant under the replacement of $q$ by $-q$, and $\pm q$ are the two elements with the same action.

Corollary. A rotation of the traceless Hermitian space by the angle $2\theta$ is produced by the rotor of the angle $\theta$, so the rotor turns by half the angle in this picture as well.

Proof. For $q=e^{i\theta(\vec n\cdot\vec\sigma)/2}$ the conjugated matrix $qXq^{*}$ is the rotation of $X$ about the axis $\vec n$ by the angle $2\theta$, which is the statement that the rotor angle is half the rotation angle.

Summary

Every rotation at order two has exactly two square roots in the rotation group, namely $e^{tJ/2}$ and its negative, and there are no others. The squaring map of the circle onto itself is therefore a covering of degree two, with the antipodal map as its deck transformation, and the angle of the rotor is half the angle of the rotation.

The ambiguity is not removable: a continuous choice of a rotor is possible only on an arc shorter than a full turn, and a full turn of the rotor returns minus the rotor. The same two signs appear in $\mathrm{SU}(2)$, where $\pm q$ act in the same way on the traceless Hermitian matrices.

Summary of Notation

Symbol Meaning
$R=e^{tJ}$ a rotation of the plane
$e^{tJ/2}$ the rotor, a square root of $R$
$J$ the right-angle rotation
$\pm q$ the two rotors in $\mathrm{SU}(2)$
$\vec n\cdot\vec\sigma$ the traceless Hermitian direction

Further Reading