The Three Sectors of the Split-Biquaternion Algebra

Introduction

Two predicates cut the split-biquaternion algebra $\mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}\cong\mathbb{H}\oplus\mathbb{H}$ into four sectors: the reduced norm $\Delta=|Q_+|^2|Q_-|^2$ is zero or non-zero, and the reduced characteristic polynomial $p_{\tilde Q}=p_+p_-$ has a repeated root or not. The four sectors are the sectors $\Sigma_{ij}$, with $i=1$ for $\Delta\neq0$ and $j=1$ for spectral regularity. Three of them are non-empty; the fourth, $\Sigma_{01}$, is empty. This article defines the sectors, proves that three are non-empty and one is empty, and describes each one with its dimension and closure. The spectral criterion is Spectral Regularity and Degeneracy in the Split-Biquaternion Algebra; the comparison is The Reduced Norm and Spectral Degeneracy in the Split-Biquaternion Algebra.

Conventions. The split complex unit is $j$, with $j^2=1$, and $\tilde\Pi_{1,2}=\tfrac12(1\pm j)$. An element is $\tilde Q=Q_+\tilde\Pi_1+Q_-\tilde\Pi_2$ with $Q_\pm=t_\pm+\vec q_\pm$, $t_\pm\in\mathbb{R}$, $\vec q_\pm=\sum_k q_{\pm k}\vec e_k$, $|\vec q_\pm|^2=\sum_k q_{\pm k}^2$, and $|Q_\pm|^2=t_\pm^2+|\vec q_\pm|^2$. The reduced norm is $\Delta=|Q_+|^2|Q_-|^2$. The spectrum is $\{t_+\pm i|\vec q_+|\}\cup\{t_-\pm i|\vec q_-|\}$, and a repeated root occurs exactly when $\vec q_+=0$, or $\vec q_-=0$, or $t_+=t_-$ and $|\vec q_+|=|\vec q_-|$. The algebra is Split-Biquaternion Algebra; the norm and zero divisors are Split-Biquaternion Norm and Invertibility and Split-Biquaternion Zero Divisors.

The Sectors

Definition (sectors). For $i,j\in\{0,1\}$, the sector $\Sigma_{ij}$ is the set of elements with $\Delta\neq0$ if $i=1$ and $\Delta=0$ if $i=0$, and with no repeated root of $p_{\tilde Q}$ if $j=1$ and with a repeated root if $j=0$. Explicitly,

$$ \Sigma_{11}=\{\Delta\neq0,\ \text{spectrally regular}\},\qquad \Sigma_{10}=\{\Delta\neq0,\ \text{spectrally degenerate}\}, $$

$$ \Sigma_{01}=\{\Delta=0,\ \text{spectrally regular}\},\qquad \Sigma_{00}=\{\Delta=0,\ \text{spectrally degenerate}\}. $$

The index $i$ refers to the reduced norm, not to a half's quaternion norm. The index $j$ refers to the reduced polynomial $p_{\tilde Q}$; the full operator polynomial is $p_{\tilde Q}^2$, so the two have the same root set.

Proposition (explicit conditions). The sectors are also given by

$$ \Sigma_{11}=\{\Delta\neq0,\ \vec q_+\neq0,\ \vec q_-\neq0,\ (t_+,|\vec q_+|)\neq(t_-,|\vec q_-|)\}, $$

$$ \Sigma_{10}=\{\Delta\neq0,\ \vec q_+=0\text{ or }\vec q_-=0\text{ or }(t_+=t_-,\ |\vec q_+|=|\vec q_-|)\}, $$

$$ \Sigma_{00}=\{\Delta=0\},\qquad \Sigma_{01}=\{\Delta=0,\ \vec q_+\neq0,\ \vec q_-\neq0,\ (t_+,|\vec q_+|)\neq(t_-,|\vec q_-|)\}. $$

Proof. The repeated-root criterion says that a repeated root occurs exactly in the three displayed cases. Its negation is that both vector parts are non-zero and the pairs $(t_\pm,|\vec q_\pm|)$ differ. On $\Sigma_{11}$ that negation holds; on $\Sigma_{10}$ it fails and $\Delta\neq0$; on $\Sigma_{00}$ the reduced norm vanishes; on $\Sigma_{01}$ the negation holds and the reduced norm vanishes.

Theorem (partition). The algebra is the disjoint union

$$ \mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}=\Sigma_{11}\sqcup\Sigma_{10}\sqcup\Sigma_{01}\sqcup\Sigma_{00}. $$

Proof. Each element has exactly one truth value for $\Delta\neq0$ and exactly one for "spectrally regular", hence lies in exactly one of the four combinations.

Three Non-Empty Sectors and One Empty Sector

Theorem (the count). $\Sigma_{11}$, $\Sigma_{10}$ and $\Sigma_{00}$ are non-empty, and $\Sigma_{01}$ is empty.

Proof. Three witnesses and one theorem.

  • $\Sigma_{11}$. Take $Q_+=\vec e_x$ and $Q_-=2\vec e_z$. Then $\Delta=1\cdot4=4$. The plus spectrum is $\{i,-i\}$ and the minus spectrum is $\{2i,-2i\}$; they are disjoint, so the element is spectrally regular.
  • $\Sigma_{10}$. Take $Q_+=1$ and $Q_-=\vec e_z$. Then $\Delta=1$. The plus half is scalar, so $p_+=(\lambda-1)^2$ has the repeated root $1$; the element is spectrally degenerate.
  • $\Sigma_{00}$. Take $Q_+=0$ and $Q_-=1$. Then $\Delta=0$; the element is a zero divisor, hence spectrally degenerate.

For $\Sigma_{01}$, suppose $\Delta=0$. By the zero criterion, $Q_+=0$ or $Q_-=0$. A zero half is the zero scalar, so $\vec q_+=0$ or $\vec q_-=0$; by the repeated-root criterion, $p_{\tilde Q}$ has a repeated root. Hence no element of $\{\Delta=0\}$ is spectrally regular, and $\Sigma_{01}=\varnothing$.

Corollary (three sectors). The algebra is the disjoint union of the three non-empty sectors

$$ \mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}=\Sigma_{11}\sqcup\Sigma_{10}\sqcup\Sigma_{00}. $$

The fourth sector is empty, so the partition has three members.

The Sector $\Sigma_{11}$: Reduced-Norm-Regular, Spectrally Regular

Description. $\Sigma_{11}$ consists of the invertibles whose two halves are both non-scalar and whose half-spectra are disjoint. It is the complement of the set where one half is scalar or the two spectra meet.

Theorem (dimension and topology). $\Sigma_{11}$ is open and dense in $\mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}\cong\mathbb{R}^8$, has real dimension $8$, and its complement $S$ is closed of real dimension $6$. Hence $\Sigma_{11}$ has full measure and is the generic sector.

Proof. Let

$$ S=\{\vec q_+=0\}\cup\{\vec q_-=0\}\cup\{t_+=t_-,\ |\vec q_+|=|\vec q_-|\}. $$

The first two sets are linear subspaces of dimension $5$. The third contains a $6$-dimensional piece, with $t_+=t_-$, $\vec q_+\neq0$, and a unit direction for $\vec q_-$; its remaining part is the diagonal scalar line of dimension $2$. Their union is closed of dimension $6$. Its complement is exactly $\Sigma_{11}$, and since $S$ is closed of dimension $6$, that complement is open, dense and of full measure.

Proposition (inverse closure). If $\tilde Q\in\Sigma_{11}$, then $\tilde Q^{-1}\in\Sigma_{11}$.

Proof. The halves of the inverse are $Q_\pm^{-1}$, both non-zero. A quaternion is scalar exactly when its inverse is scalar, so both inverse halves are non-scalar. The spectrum of $Q_\pm^{-1}$ is the image of the spectrum of $Q_\pm$ under $z\mapsto z^{-1}$; since inversion is injective, disjointness is preserved. Finally $\Delta(\tilde Q^{-1})=\Delta(\tilde Q)^{-1}\neq0$.

Proposition (not product closed). The product of two elements of $\Sigma_{11}$ need not lie in $\Sigma_{11}$.

Proof. Take $Q_+=\vec e_x$ and $Q_-=2\vec e_z$, an element of $\Sigma_{11}$. Its square has halves $\vec e_x^2=-1$ and $(2\vec e_z)^2=-4$, both non-zero real scalars. It is invertible with a repeated root, hence lies in $\Sigma_{10}$.

The Sector $\Sigma_{10}$: Reduced-Norm-Regular, Spectrally Degenerate

Description. $\Sigma_{10}$ consists of the invertibles with a repeated root. The repetition has two causes: one half is scalar, or the two non-scalar half-spectra meet.

Definition (the three pieces). Put

$$ \Sigma_{10}^{+}=\{\vec q_+=0,\ t_+\neq0,\ Q_-\neq0\},\qquad \Sigma_{10}^{-}=\{\vec q_-=0,\ t_-\neq0,\ Q_+\neq0\}, $$

$$ \Sigma_{10}^{\mathrm{m}}=\{t_+=t_-,\ |\vec q_+|=|\vec q_-|>0\}. $$

Proposition (decomposition). $\Sigma_{10}=\Sigma_{10}^{+}\cup\Sigma_{10}^{-}\cup\Sigma_{10}^{\mathrm{m}}$.

Proof. If a half is scalar and non-zero, the element lies in $\Sigma_{10}^{+}$ or $\Sigma_{10}^{-}$, and $\Delta\neq0$ exactly when the other half is non-zero. If no half is scalar and the spectra meet, both vector parts are non-zero, $t_+=t_-$, and the norms are equal, so the element lies in $\Sigma_{10}^{\mathrm{m}}$. Conversely, each of the three pieces has $\Delta\neq0$ and a repeated root.

Theorem (dimension and closure). $\Sigma_{10}$ has real dimension $6$, empty interior, and closure

$$ \overline{\Sigma_{10}}=\Sigma_{10}\cup\Sigma_{00}=S. $$

It is neither open nor closed.

Proof. Each of $\Sigma_{10}^{+}$ and $\Sigma_{10}^{-}$ has dimension $1+4=5$; $\Sigma_{10}^{\mathrm{m}}$ has dimension $1+3+2=6$. The union has dimension $6$. It has empty interior because it is contained in $S$, which has dimension $6$ in $\mathbb{R}^8$. The closure of $\Sigma_{10}$ is $S$: every point of $\Sigma_{00}$ is a limit of points of $\Sigma_{10}$ obtained by perturbing its zero halves to small non-zero scalars, and every other point of $S$ lies in $\Sigma_{10}$. Since $S$ is closed and strictly larger than $\Sigma_{10}$, the sector is not closed; since it has empty interior, it is not open.

Theorem (no defect). Every element of $\Sigma_{10}$ is semisimple. The repeated root is a coalescence of eigenvalues, not a Jordan block.

Proof. This is the semisimplicity theorem of Spectral Regularity and Degeneracy in the Split-Biquaternion Algebra: each half lies in the division algebra $\mathbb{H}$, hence is semisimple, and a direct sum of semisimple elements is semisimple. On the scalar pieces the minimal polynomial of the scalar half is linear; on the meeting piece the shared root occurs in two different summands and is recorded once.

The Sector $\Sigma_{00}$: Reduced-Norm-Degenerate

Description. $\Sigma_{00}$ consists of the zero divisors together with the origin. It is the union of the two four-dimensional subspaces

$$ Z_+=\{Q_+=0\},\qquad Z_-=\{Q_-=0\}, $$

which meet only at $0$.

Theorem (dimension, closure and nilpotents). $\Sigma_{00}$ is closed, has real dimension $4$, and is the union of two $4$-planes that meet at the origin. It contains no non-zero nilpotent. Every element of $\Sigma_{00}$ is semisimple.

Proof. The condition $Q_+=0$ is four real linear equations, so $Z_+$ has dimension $4$; likewise $Z_-$. Their intersection is $Q_+=Q_-=0$, the origin. The set $\Sigma_{00}=Z_+\cup Z_-$ is closed, and its dimension is $4$. If $\tilde Q^2=0$, then $Q_+^2=0$ and $Q_-^2=0$; a division algebra has no non-zero nilpotent, so $Q_+=Q_-=0$ and $\tilde Q=0$. Semisimplicity is the general theorem for all elements of $\mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}$.

Proposition (spectrum). Every element of $\Sigma_{00}$ is spectrally degenerate. If $Q_+=0$ and $Q_-\neq0$, the spectrum is $\{0\}\cup\{t_-\pm i|\vec q_-|\}$, and the value $0$ is repeated; the same holds with the halves exchanged.

Proof. The zero half has $t=0$ and $\vec q=0$, so its reduced polynomial is $\lambda^2$; the repeated-root criterion applies. The displayed spectrum is the union formula of the spectral article.

Remark (the defining equation). The set $\Sigma_{00}$ is not the zero set of the split-biquaternion norm: that norm is anisotropic and vanishes only at $0$. It is the zero set of the reduced norm $\Delta$, a real quartic that factors as $|Q_+|^2|Q_-|^2$.

The Absence of a Defective Stratum

Definition (defective). An element is defective when it is not semisimple, equivalently when its minimal polynomial has a repeated factor.

Theorem (no defective stratum). Every element of $\mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}$ is semisimple. Hence no sector contains a defective stratum.

Proof. Each half lies in the division algebra $\mathbb{H}$ and is semisimple. The minimal polynomial of the pair is the least common multiple of the two half-minimal-polynomials, and a least common multiple of squarefree polynomials is squarefree.

The decomposition of $\Sigma_{10}$ into the scalar pieces and the meeting locus is therefore by the cause of the repeated root, not by defect. The biquaternion degenerate sector has nilpotent and Jordan strata; here neither occurs, only the scalar stratum. A nilpotent in a product would have nilpotent components, and a division algebra has none.

The Sectors at a Glance

Sector Condition Description Dimension
$\Sigma_{11}$ $\Delta\neq0$, $\vec q_\pm\neq0$, $(t_+,\lvert\vec q_+\rvert)\neq(t_-,\lvert\vec q_-\rvert)$ Units with two non-scalar halves and disjoint spectra; open and dense $8$
$\Sigma_{10}$ $\Delta\neq0$ and ($\vec q_+=0$ or $\vec q_-=0$ or ($t_+=t_-$, $\lvert\vec q_+\rvert=\lvert\vec q_-\rvert$)) Units with a scalar half or meeting spectra; semisimple, empty interior $6$
$\Sigma_{00}$ $\Delta=0$ Zero divisors and $0$; one half zero; two $4$-planes $4$
$\Sigma_{01}$ $\Delta=0$ and spectrally regular Empty ---

Summary

Two predicates cut the algebra into four sectors. Spectral regularity and reduced-norm regularity are not independent: $\Sigma_{01}$ is empty, because a vanishing reduced norm forces one half to be zero, and a zero half is a repeated root at zero. The three non-empty sectors are $\Sigma_{11}$, the invertibles with two non-scalar halves and disjoint spectra; $\Sigma_{10}$, the invertibles with a scalar half or meeting spectra; and $\Sigma_{00}$, the zero divisors and the origin.

The dimensions are $8$, $6$ and $4$. $\Sigma_{11}$ is open and dense; $\Sigma_{10}$ has empty interior and closure $S$; $\Sigma_{00}$ is closed, the union of two $4$-planes. Every element is semisimple, so there is no defective stratum: the repeated roots are repetitions of eigenvalues, not Jordan blocks. The biquaternion algebra has a Jordan part and nilpotents; the product of two division algebras removes both.

Summary of Notation

Symbol Meaning
$\mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}\cong\mathbb{H}\oplus\mathbb{H}$ Split-biquaternion algebra
$\tilde Q=Q_+\tilde\Pi_1+Q_-\tilde\Pi_2$ Idempotent decomposition
$Q_\pm=t_\pm+\vec q_\pm$ A half
$\Delta=\lvert Q_+\rvert^2\lvert Q_-\rvert^2$ Reduced norm
$\Sigma_{ij}$ Sector with reduced-norm index $i$ and spectral index $j$
$\Sigma_{11}$ Reduced-norm regular, spectrally regular
$\Sigma_{10}$ Reduced-norm regular, spectrally degenerate
$\Sigma_{00}$ Reduced-norm degenerate, spectrally degenerate
$\Sigma_{01}$ Reduced-norm degenerate, spectrally regular; empty
$S=\Sigma_{10}\cup\Sigma_{00}$ Complement of $\Sigma_{11}$ and closure of $\Sigma_{10}$
$Z_\pm=\{Q_\pm=0\}$ The two $4$-planes of $\Sigma_{00}$

Further Reading