The Rotor as a Square Root of a Rotation: the Two Signs and the Double Cover at $n=4$

Introduction

Every rotation of four-space is the two-sided action $X\mapsto\rho X\rho^{-1}$ of a rotor, the rotors $\rho$ and $-\rho$ give the same rotation, and the map from the rotors to the rotations is a covering of degree two from $\mathrm{Spin}(4)=SU(2)\times SU(2)$ onto $SO(4)$, whose finite shadow is the group of order $32$ of the signed permutations acting on a group of order $64$.

The article defines the rotor in the biquaternion algebra, proves that the two-sided action is a rotation and that the two signs give the same one, computes the covering and its kernel, exhibits the extraspecial group of order $32$ as the finite shadow of the cover, separates the two components of $O(4)$ from the connected $SO(4)$, and identifies the generator of $\pi_1(SO(4))=\mathbb{Z}_2$ with the belt.

It assumes Rotors Acting on the Bivector Space: the Adjoint Action at $n=4$ and The Lie Algebra $\operatorname{Skew}_4\cong\mathfrak{so}(4)$. The model at order two is The Rotor as a Square Root of a Rotation: the Two Signs and the Double Cover; the frame that generates the even words is Where the Rotor Leaves $M_4(\mathbb{C})$: the Even Subalgebra and $Cl(4)$.

The Rotor and the Two Signs

Definition. A rotor is an even product $\rho=v_1v_2\cdots v_{2m}$ of unit vectors of the algebra, and a unit rotor is one with $\rho\rho^{\natural}=e_t$.

Proposition. For a unit rotor the map $\Phi_\rho(X)=\rho X\rho^{\natural}$ preserves the algebra, is real-linear, and preserves the norm $X X^{\natural}$.

Proof. $\Phi_\rho(X)\Phi_\rho(X)^{\natural}=\rho X\rho^{\natural}\rho X^{\natural}\rho^{\natural}=\rho X X^{\natural}\rho^{\natural}$, which equals $XX^{\natural}$ when $\rho\rho^{\natural}=e_t$ and the scalar part is central.

Corollary. $\Phi_\rho$ is an orthogonal transformation of the four-dimensional real space, and $\Phi_{\rho}\Phi_{\sigma}=\Phi_{\rho\sigma}$.

Proof. Preservation of the norm on a real space of dimension four gives orthogonality, and the composition law is associativity.

Theorem. $\Phi_\rho=\Phi_{-\rho}$, so the two signs of a rotor give the same rotation.

Proof. $(-\rho)X(-\rho)^{\natural}=\rho X\rho^{\natural}$, since the two signs cancel.

Corollary. The map from rotors to rotations is at least two to one, and no rotor is its own negative.

Proof. The kernel contains $\pm e_t$, which are distinct.

The square root. If $\rho^{2}=\sigma$ then $\Phi_\rho^{2}=\Phi_\sigma$, so a rotor is a square root of the rotation it induces only when the induced rotation is the square of another; the useful statement is the other way round, that every rotation has a rotor and the rotor is unique up to sign.

Proof. The composition law and the theorem.

The Two-Sided Action

Theorem. Every element of $SO(4)$ is $\Phi_\rho$ for some unit rotor $\rho$, and the rotors form the group $\mathrm{Spin}(4)$.

Proof. In the axis-free frame the four left multiplications and the four right multiplications generate a group of signed permutations containing $SO(4)$ in the sense of Lie algebras; at the level of the Lie algebra every antisymmetric matrix is $L_u+R_v$ with $u,v$ imaginary, and exponentiating gives $\Phi_{e^{u}e^{v}}$ with the two one-sided unit quaternions. The rotors form a group because the product of two rotors is a rotor.

Corollary. $\mathrm{Spin}(4)\cong SU(2)\times SU(2)$, of real dimension $6$, equal to the dimension of $SO(4)$.

Proof. The left unit quaternions form a copy of $SU(2)$ and the right ones another, they commute, and the pair $(-1,-1)$ acts as the identity on the algebra.

Corollary. The two-sided action is the general rotor action at order four, while at order three the one-sided action suffices; the second quaternion is the new ingredient of the dimension.

Proof. $\mathfrak{so}(3)$ has dimension $3$ and is covered by one copy of $SU(2)$; $\mathfrak{so}(4)$ has dimension $6$ and needs two.

The two factors as the two isoclinic families. A rotor which is a single left quaternion gives a left-isoclinic rotation, a single right quaternion gives a right-isoclinic one, and a general rotor is the product of the two.

Proof. The left action rotates both planes by the same angle, the right action by opposite angles, and the product adds the two contributions.

The Double Cover

Theorem. The map $\pi:\mathrm{Spin}(4)\to SO(4)$, $\rho\mapsto\Phi_\rho$, is a surjective Lie group homomorphism with kernel $\{\pm e_t\}$, hence a covering of degree two.

Proof. Surjectivity is the theorem of the previous section; the kernel is the set of rotors acting trivially, which is $\pm e_t$ because the action is faithful up to sign and the representation is faithful; a homomorphism of Lie groups with discrete kernel of two elements is a covering.

Corollary. $\pi_1(SO(4))=\mathbb{Z}_2$, and $\mathrm{Spin}(4)$ is simply connected.

Proof. The total space of a covering of a connected manifold with simply connected total space computes the fundamental group of the base as the fibre; $SU(2)\times SU(2)$ is simply connected, and the fibre has two points.

Corollary. Every rotation has exactly two rotors, and a continuous path of rotations lifts to a path of rotors only if the path is trivial in $\pi_1$; the full turn is not.

Proof. The two preimages and the lifting criterion for coverings.

The two signs are not a convention. The sign of a rotor is a genuine ambiguity of the square root: there is no continuous choice of a rotor for a continuous family of rotations going once around the nontrivial loop.

Proof. A continuous choice would be a section of the covering, which would split the nontrivial double cover.

The Finite Shadow

Theorem. The sixteen matrices $T_{\mu\nu}=L_{\mu}R_{\nu}$ and their negatives form a group of order $32$, isomorphic to $(Q_8\times Q_8)/\{\pm(1,1)\}$, the central product $Q_8\circ Q_8$.

Proof. Each $T_{\mu\nu}$ is a signed permutation of determinant one; the products follow $T_{\mu\nu}T_{\rho\sigma}=\pm T_{\mu\rho,\sigma\nu}$, and the sign bookkeeping is that of the two copies of $Q_8$.

Corollary. The group of order $32$ is the image under the double cover of the group $Q_8\times Q_8$ of order $64$, and the kernel is again the pair $\pm(1,1)$.

Proof. Each $T_{\mu\nu}$ is the image of the pair $(L_\mu,R_\nu)$ of signed permutation quaternions, and the pair $(-1,-1)$ maps to the identity.

Corollary. The finite shadow of the double cover is $64\to32$, the same ratio as $SU(2)\times SU(2)\to SO(4)$, and the group of order $32$ lies inside $SO(4)$.

Proof. All the $T_{\mu\nu}$ have determinant one, so they are rotations, and the ratio of the orders is two.

The extraspecial structure. The group of order $32$ has centre of order two and is extraspecial, so its finite representation theory shadows the covering exactly.

Proof. The centre is $\{\pm\mathrm I_4\}$, and the quotient by it is elementary abelian of order $16$.

The Two Components

Theorem. $O(4)$ has two connected components, distinguished by the sign of the determinant; $SO(4)$ is the identity component and is connected.

Proof. The determinant is continuous on $O(4)$ and takes the values $\pm1$; the group $SO(4)$ is the image of the connected group $\mathrm{Spin}(4)$ under a continuous map.

Corollary. A reflection is not a rotor action, and every element of $O(4)$ is a rotor action composed with a fixed reflection.

Proof. A rotor action has determinant one, so a reflection has determinant minus one and is not of that form; the quotient of the two components is of order two.

Corollary. The two components are the two cosets of $SO(4)$ in $O(4)$, and each is a copy of $SO(4)$ as a manifold.

Proof. The cosets of the identity component in a Lie group are the components, and the action by a reflection is a diffeomorphism.

The dimension count. $\dim SO(4)=6$, $\dim O(4)=6$, and the two components are each of dimension six.

Proof. The dimension of a Lie group is that of its Lie algebra, and the two components are diffeomorphic.

The Loop and the Belt

Theorem. The loop $t\mapsto e^{tJ}$ for $t\in[0,2\pi]$, with $J$ a complex structure, is the nontrivial element of $\pi_1(SO(4))$, and its double is contractible.

Proof. The loop lifts to $t\mapsto e^{tJ/2}$ in $\mathrm{Spin}(4)$, which returns to $-e_t$ at $t=2\pi$; the lift of the double loop returns to $e_t$, and $SU(2)\times SU(2)$ is simply connected, so the double loop is null-homotopic.

Corollary. A full turn of a rigid body does not return its rotor, and two full turns do; the belt is the physical picture of the same statement.

Proof. The lift computation and the connectedness of the path space.

Corollary. The two signs of the rotor are the two lifts of the same rotation, and only a closed loop that is twice a generator returns to the starting sign.

Proof. The kernel of the covering and the computation above.

The higher groups. At order four the same argument applies with $\mathrm{Spin}(4)$ replaced by $\mathrm{Spin}(4)$ itself, and the conclusion $\pi_1(SO(4))=\mathbb{Z}_2$ is the same for every order at least three.

Proof. The covering $\mathrm{Spin}(n)\to SO(n)$ has kernel of order two and $\mathrm{Spin}(n)$ is simply connected for $n\ge3$.

Summary

A unit rotor $\rho$ acts by $X\mapsto\rho X\rho^{-1}$, the rotors $\rho$ and $-\rho$ give the same rotation, and every rotation of four-space arises this way: the action is onto with kernel $\{\pm e_t\}$, so $\mathrm{Spin}(4)=SU(2)\times SU(2)$ covers $SO(4)$ with degree two.

At order four the rotor needs two one-sided unit quaternions, one for each factor of $\mathfrak{so}(4)=\mathfrak{sl}_2\oplus\mathfrak{sl}_2$, and the isoclinic rotations are those with one factor real. The finite shadow is the group of order $32$ of the signed permutations, the image of $Q_8\times Q_8$ of order $64$.

$SO(4)$ is connected and $O(4)$ has two components, separated by the sign of the determinant. The generator of $\pi_1(SO(4))=\mathbb{Z}_2$ is the full turn, whose lift changes the sign of the rotor and whose double returns: the belt trick.

Summary of Notation

Symbol Meaning
$\rho$ a unit rotor in the biquaternion algebra
$\Phi_\rho(X)=\rho X\rho^{\natural}$ the rotation induced by the rotor
$\mathrm{Spin}(4)=SU(2)\times SU(2)$ the group of rotors
$T_{\mu\nu}$ the sixteen signed permutations and their negatives
$Q_8\circ Q_8$ the central product of order $32$
$\pi_1(SO(4))=\mathbb{Z}_2$ the fundamental group of the rotations

Further Reading